Note: I am travelling this month. Posting will be sporadic and shorter due to limited time and equipment.
Economic Resilience on Display in Q3 GDP
U.S. economic output accelerated in the third quarter as real GDP rose at a 4.9% annualized rate. At the start of 2023, a number of forecasters, including many at the Federal Reserve, thought the U.S. economy would be either slowing or perhaps even entering a recession by the second half of the year. Instead, it is accelerating. Third quarter growth is more than double the pace of the prior period’s growth (+2.1%) and well-above what many observers estimate to be the potential growth rate in the U.S. economy today (~1.8%).
There’s no denying this is a strong outturn, but an $80.6 billion build in inventories was responsible for 1.3 percentage points of headline growth. Net exports were the largest surprise to us. We had anticipated a boost from trade, but net exports subtracted 0.1 percentage points from growth on stronger import activity, which does not immediately square with the advance monthly data. Real imports rose at a 5.7% annualized clip in Q3, or by the most in six quarters.
Still, growth is tempered a bit when we strip through some of these volatile components and look at the core parts of the economy. Real final sales to domestic purchasers were still robust but expanded at a more moderate 3.5% clip last quarter. As seen in the nearby chart, that’s still a pace well ahead of the roughly 2.3% quarterly annualized growth rate averaged over the previous expansion.
Economic growth was lifted by a robust pace of consumer spending throughout the period, as evidenced by fairly strong monthly retail sales data. Real personal consumption expenditures expanded at a 4.0% annualized pace, or the fastest rate of expansion since mid-2021 when the economy was bouncing back amid reopening. Growth was fairly broad based among major spending categories as well, though services continue to account for a majority of consumption (chart). Services spending rose at the fastest pace in over two years, and goods purchases bounced after a weak second quarter.
We will get the full release for September Personal Income & Spending tomorrow, which will include the monthly spending details, but we expect consumption ended the quarter quite strong, setting the fourth quarter up for a decent pace of growth as well.
Beyond consumer spending, residential investment was also pretty strong, seeing its first positive pace of growth in ten quarters (+3.9%). Nonresidential investment was weaker, but most of that weakness is attributed to slower equipment outlays during the period, which fell at an annualized rate of 3.8%. Structures investment (+1.6%) and intellectual property products (+2.6%) both expanded.
Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and Wells Fargo Economics
The pullback in equipment spending was a little larger than we had anticipated, though it is consistent with the separately released data on September Durable Goods out this morning. These data show that nondefense capital goods shipments, which feed into the BEA’s calculation of equipment investment, slipped 0.2% in September. The advance in broad durable goods orders in September was largely driven by a surge in aircraft orders, which we anticipated from previously released Boeing data. Equipment spending has been volatile in recent quarters, and we anticipate it will remain under pressure as borrowing conditions grow less favorable.
Third quarter growth demonstrates the U.S. economy remains resilient in the face of higher rates and still-elevated prices. While we still anticipate it will take a period of below-trend growth to ultimately sniff out inflation, we do not think this report changes much for monetary policymakers, who are set to meet next week. We still anticipate the FOMC will elect to leave rates unchanged at the conclusion of its meeting.
Policymakers had anticipated the strength exhibited in today’s report based on strong monthly data, with little of the underlying details coming as much of a surprise. Inflation also continued to moderate with the core PCE deflator easing to a 2.4% annualized pace in the third quarter.
Separately released data on jobless claims showed a slight uptick in initial claims for unemployment as well as those continuing to make claims. While both measures remain low and consistent with a tight labor market, the more persistent rise in continuing claims adds to some signs of moderation.
The recent upward move in longer-dated yields can also add to financial tightness in the economy. We thus anticipate the FOMC will remain cautious to take further action at this point. We also ultimately still anticipate the economy will show more meaningful signs of slowing later this year and early next year as tighter financial conditions more meaningfully materialize and begin to weigh on spending and investment decisions.
(…) Unfortunately, we don’t see this stellar growth rate being repeated in the fourth quarter of the year. The cumulative effects of Federal Reserve interest rate increases and reduced credit availability are showing signs of finally biting. Credit card borrowing costs are the highest since records began, car loan and personal loan rates are soaring while mortgage rates are up at 8%. At the same time, the sources of funds to spend are looking less supportive. Real household disposable income is flat lining, savings are being run down and consumer credit is starting to be paid back, with student loan repayments restarting. As such, we expect consumer spending to grow at a weaker pace in the fourth quarter with this decelerating trend continuing in 2024.
Home builder sentiment is also starting to sour, which weakens the outlook for residential construction as we head towards 2024 while that big surge in inventories seen in the third quarter may not come in as strongly in the fourth quarter.
It is obviously early days, but at this stage we see GDP growth coming in closer to 1.5% in the final three months of the year. Not terrible, but with those challenges facing the consumer sector likely intensifying, growth is set to be even weaker in 2024.
- The U.S. consumer is ‘walking towards a cliff,’ strategist warns Trouble is brewing for the U.S. economy and its pivotal consumer component.
(…) “I think the U.S. consumer is walking towards a cliff, basically,” Chris Watling, chief executive of financial advisory firm Longview Economics, told CNBC’s “Squawk Box Europe” on Tuesday.
He said that a slew of recent economic indicators had showed consumers are quickly running out of excess cash, while household savings are coming under pressure.
“Of course, retail sales have been quite strong for the last few months and everyone gets quite excited about that, but, actually, if you look at what’s going on, the household savings ratio has been run down, and, in fact, real income growth has been negative for three months,” Watling said.
“So, it’s not quite all good news. I mean, quite the reverse, I think there are some real challenges coming for the U.S. consumer.” (…)
“We see at the margins the consumer is under a lot of pressure and, in fact, the labor market is under a lot of pressure as well. We had a good payrolls month, but if you look at a lot of the indicators of where the labor market is likely to go, a lot of them are fraying at the edges,” Watling said.
“We’re going to get to the point in the next months when I think the labor market starts to deteriorate more meaningfully and that’ll kickstart the recession when we get there,” he added. (…)
Some facts FYI:
- Since the pandemic, real expenditures have exceeded both real disposable income and real labor income. Sustainable?
- Sustainable only with more credit or lower savings, which did not happen this cycle:
- Helicopter money is responsible for the spending surge. The so-called excess savings generated excess spending. Wells Fargo says that “the benchmark revisions to the National Accounts caused some pretty big changes to our measure of excess savings again. Essentially, the data now suggest there is $1.1T remaining in excess savings through August, whereas the previous data suggested only about $339B remaining through July.”
- Not everybody agrees with this but Wells Fargo supports its view with this chart showing “excess deposits”:
- The only problem with these “excess deposits” is that inflation has brought their real spending power below trend. In real terms, helicopter money has disappeared.
So we are back to the old normal where consumption generally grows with labor income, up 5.6% YoY in September, +5.3% a.r. in the last 3 months and +6.6% a.r. in the last 2 even if wages grew only 2.7% a.r..
The October flash PMI provides a few clues of the most recent trends:
At 51.0 in October, the headline S&P Global Flash US PMI Composite Output Index rose from 50.2 at the end of the third quarter to signal a modest uptick in business activity. Growth in output was the strongest since July, albeit only slight overall.
The overall upturn was supported by expansions in activity at manufacturers and service providers at the start of the fourth quarter. Production at manufacturing firms rose at the quickest pace since April, while output growth at service sector firms was the fastest in three months. (…)
US businesses continued to hire additional workers during October, albeit at a slightly reduced pace compared to September. (…)
Companies raised their average selling prices for goods and services at the slowest pace since June 2020 in October.
Slow growth, but growth nonetheless, with subdued inflation.
Evergrande Talks With Holdout Creditors Ahead of Wind-Up Hearing Risk of liquidation looms as builder reassesses restructuring
(…) The clock is ticking on Evergrande, the world’s most indebted developer with about 2.39 trillion yuan ($327 billion) of total liabilities. It faces a winding-up hearing in Hong Kong on Monday, where it needs to present “concrete” restructuring progress to help avoid the once-unthinkable risk of a liquidation. The fate of Evergrande and even bigger peer Country Garden Holdings Co.—deemed in default for the first time ever this week—is of broader significance to an economy where the property market and related industries account for about 20% of gross domestic product.
Evergrande said last week that it’s revising the terms of its restructuring plan without giving details, after scrapping creditor meetings at the last-minute in September and saying it would need to reassess its proposals. (…)
- Country Garden’s Missed Bond Payment Triggers CDS Payout Note’s trustee says coupon nonpayment an ‘event of default’
(…) With $186 billion of total liabilities, Country Garden is one of the world’s most indebted builders and a symbol of China’s broader property debt woes. (…)
A messy overhaul by Country Garden risks sending the sector into deeper turmoil and posing a threat to social stability, given its large number of projects and heavy presence in smaller cities. (…)
- China Selloff Threatens $27 Billion of ‘Snowball’ Derivatives Hitting knock-in level may trigger selling of index futures
Another 10% decline in a major Chinese equity gauge may trigger a wave of selling in index futures tied to structured products, adding fresh risks to the slumping stock market.
Investors face losses in complex “snowball” derivatives at maturity when a benchmark falls below a so-called knock-in level. For those tied to the CSI Smallcap 500 Index, the average threshold is 4,865, according to estimates by China International Capital Corp. The gauge traded at around 5,417 as of 9:52 a.m. Friday.
A relentless rout in Chinese stocks has turned the spotlight on the risk of those derivatives, which promise bond-like coupons as long as underlying assets trade within a certain range. Snowballs, similar to autocallables in other countries, gained popularity in 2021 among China’s institutional and wealthy investors and have expanded into a market worth $27 billion. Brokers may rush to liquidate hedging positions once the knock-in level is reached.
Investors in South Korea, another huge market for structured notes, have billions of dollars worth of bets placed on products tied to the Hang Seng China Enterprises Index that are also at risk.
Snowball notes with the CSI 1000 as the underlying index have an average knock-in barrier at 4,997, according to CICC estimates. That’s about 14% below Friday morning levels. (…)
“If there is forced selling of index futures, the impact could spill over as the drop in derivatives will hit sentiment or could force closing of long stock positions,” said Yu Yingbo, fund manager at Shenzhen Qianhai United Fortune Fund Management Co. Ltd. Still, the regulators should be less worried due to the tighter oversight in recent years, he added.
CICC estimated that any selling of index futures triggered by the breach of knock-in levels will still have limited impact on the spot stock market, as traders will reduce positions in a “diversified manner” and the volume will be small when compared to the total futures market.

Source: The Daily Shot
Source: 