The enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it’s the illusion of knowledge (Stephen Hawking)

It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so (Mark Twain)

Invest with smart knowledge and objective odds

NEW$ & VIEW$ (15 JANUARY 2016): Down!

Oil Falls Back Below $30 With Brent Discount Biggest Since 2010

West Texas Intermediate futures dropped as much as 5.8 percent in New York and are down more than 10 percent for the week. The grade had slipped below $30 a barrel on Tuesday for the first time since 2003. International sanctions on Iran may be lifted soon, allowing for a boost in oil shipments from the fifth-biggest member of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries. (…)

Ben Hunt gets the Fed involved:

(…) For example, we all know that it’s the overwhelming oil “glut” that’s driving oil prices down and wreaking havoc in capital markets, right? It’s all about OPEC versus US frackers, right?

Here’s a 5-year chart of the broad-weighted US dollar index (this is the index the Fed publishes, which – unlike the DXY index and its >50% Euro weighting – weights all US trading partners on a pro rata basis) versus the price of WTI crude oil. The red line marks Yellen’s announcement of the Fed’s current tightening bias in the summer of 2014.

image

Ummm … this nearly perfect inverse relationship is not an accident. I’m not saying that supply and demand don’t matter. Of course they do. What I’m saying is that divergent monetary policy and its reflection in currency exchange rates matters even more. Where is the greatest monetary policy divergence in the world today? Between the US and China. What currency is the largest contributor to the Fed’s broad-weighted dollar index? The yuan (21.5%). THIS is what you need to pay attention to in order to understand what’s going on with oil. THIS is why the game of Chicken between the Fed and the PBOC is so much more relevant to markets than the game of Chicken between Saudi Arabia and Texas. (…)

It’s not just oil that is having a horrid time, with industrial metals heading for their second weekly drop in a row as all base metals fell on the London Metal Exchange.

Global slowdown depresses base metals prices

Recently, Moody’s industrial metals price index sank to its lowest reading since May 28, 2009. As of January 13, the base metals price index — one of the better coincident indicators of global economic activity — was off by -7.3% since year-end 2015 and down by -26.4% from a year earlier. The latter was deeper than the -18.5% year-over-year plunge by the base metals price index’s latest moving 52-week average.

In 2015, the base metals price index’s yearlong average sank by -17.8%. Notwithstanding the severity of 2015’s setback, the consensus projects a 3.0% annual increase by 2015’s world economy. . Though the latter lags the world economy’s 3.8% average annual increase of previous recovery years, the record suggests that the consensus view will prove too high given the harshness of industrial metals price deflation.

According to a sample that begins in 1979, 2015’s annual average decline by the base metals price index was the third worst on record. The two deeper calendar-year setbacks were 1982’s -20.8% and 2009’s -20.0%, or when the percent change in world economic activity approximated 0.8% and 0.0%, respectively. In addition, 1998’s fourth deepest annual contraction by the base metals price index of -16.9% was joined by a well below-average 2.5% gain for the world economy.

More than a cursory examination of the data favors slower-than-anticipated growth for the world economy. According to a regression model that explains world economic growth in terms of the annual percent changes of the industrial metals price index and US real GDP, 2015’s annual increase by world real GDP may be closer to 2.5% than to the projected 3.0%.

image

The caveat is that the current commodity price collapse is more a supply than a demand problem as CRU demonstrated at a recent Scotia Capital conference:

Despite a general economic slowdown, China continues to face deficits in many commodities, including copper, nickel, zinc, iron ore, and potash. The value of imports has declined on the back of lower commodity prices, but not volume. In fact, the pace of commodity imports remains in a secular uptrend, as represented by an index of leading imported commodities over at least the past 22 months, and CRU thinks this indicates healthy demand growth, and not a collapse like some believe.

image

CRU believes much of the commodity price decline seen to date is not due to a lack of demand, but rather, a result of overcapacity. However, supply in China is self-correcting on the back of: (1) shutdowns due to unprofitability; (2) production curtailments by producers; and (3) government-imposed closures. Moreover, the Chinese government has been withdrawing subsidies and incentives for smaller producers (e.g. electricity, transportation, etc.), to encourage consolidation. CRU estimates planned capacity closures will negatively impact China’s GDP by ~0.6%.

Hailed as the biggest initiative since the opening of China, the One Belt One Road (OBOR) initiative calls for the development of an economic corridor that connects 60+ countries. This is could increase China’s outward direct investment to $300B/yr from $100B/yr currently, with much of it focused on commodities required for the planned infrastructure build, including new rail, road, ports and pipelines. CRU estimates that the policy could increase steel requirements by as much as 100M mt/yr.

I also believe it is mainly a supply issue after years of over-investment based on free money and extrapolating China’s demand, but demand is also pretty tame currently as evidenced by world industrial production, barely rising YoY.

Dollar in Best Run Since July on Haven Bid Even as Fed Odds Fall

An index of the U.S. currency against 10 of its peers rose for a third week, the longest stretch since July, amid demand for haven assets as oil dropped below $30 for the first time in more than a decade and Chinese stocks led a global rout. Futures show 26 percent odds the Fed will tighten policy by its March meeting, down from 41 percent as of the end of last week. (…)

Global Malaise Spurs U.S. Growth Worries Concerns are mounting over whether the U.S. economy and financial markets can remain upright while so much of the world teeters.

(…) Forecasters in The Wall Street Journal’s latest survey of economists said there is a 17% chance the U.S. will enter a recession in 2016, the highest percentage in three years. And 80% said they see downside risks to the economy.

“To lose the U.S. expansion, there has to be some transfer mechanism of global angst to the domestic U.S. economy,” said Ellen Zentner, chief U.S. economist at Morgan Stanley.Falling stocks and deteriorating credit markets could do the trick, she said. (…)

They expect the economy will grow 2.5% in the coming year and the unemployment rate will fall further to 4.7% by year’s end.

They are less optimistic about emerging economies: 53% of economists surveyed think these markets will weaken, while only 18% think they will strengthen. (…)

Deutsche Bank: Where is the slowdown?

How can the US economy create 257,000 jobs when the dollar is strong and oil prices are low and HY energy spreads are widening? Because the elephant in the room is the service sector, which benefits from lower oil prices. Bottom line: Don’t interpret 10y rates in the US at 2.2% as a sign that the US economy is unhealthy (…)

Shift in Inflation Expectations Clouds Interest-Rate Outlook Investors show growing doubt that the Federal Reserve will successfully spur inflation to climb back to its 2% target after running below that level for more than three and a half years.

(…) Yield movements in the Treasury inflation-protected securities, or TIPS, market indicate that compensation for inflation expected in five to 10 years has dropped to 1.56% annually, according to Barclays. That is down from 1.67% when the Fed raised short-term rates in December. Moreover, it is down from 2.5% two years ago. (…)

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s survey of consumer expectations, released this week, found households in December expected 2.8% inflation over the next three years and 2.5% inflation over the next year, both down from 3% a year earlier. 

More data on consumer inflation expectations come Friday from the University of Michigan. The Michigan survey in December showed expectations of 2.6% inflation over the next year and a 2.6% annual rate for the next 5 years, down from 2.8% a year earlier. (…)

Fed Chairwoman Janet Yellen said in a Dec. 2 speech that “convincing evidence that longer-term inflation expectations have moved lower would be a concern” and could make “the attainment of our 2% inflation goal more difficult.”

She said in mid-December, “I still judge that inflation expectations are reasonably well anchored.” (…)

U.S. Import Prices Down 1.2% in December Declining prices for imports, even beyond oil, appears likely to exert downward pressure on inflation in the U.S. well into this year.

It was the sixth straight monthly decline. From a year earlier, import prices were down 8.2% in December. The year-over-year figure has declined for 17 consecutive months. (…)

Imported petroleum prices fell 10% in December—the largest monthly decline since August. Imported oil prices are down 41.3% from a year earlier. The rout on oil prices isn’t abating. Oil prices touched below $30 a barrel this week for the first time since 2003.

But even outside of petroleum, import prices were down 0.4% in December, and have fallen 3.7% from a year earlier. That was the largest 12-month decline for the category since October 2009. (…)

In December, import prices fell in most categories, including a 1.4% drop in industrial materials excluding petroleum, a 0.3% fall in capital goods such as machinery, and a 0.1% decline in car and automotive part prices. The cost of nonagricultural foods, such as fish and distilled beverages, increased 0.5% last month, but overall food prices still fell.

The price of goods imported from China fell 1.7% in December from a year earlier, the largest 12-month decline in six years. Prices from Canada, the largest U.S. trading partner, were down 14.8% from a year earlier. The price of imports from the European Union fell 3.9%.

U.S. export prices also declined last month, possibly reflecting lackluster demand overseas. Export costs fell 1.1% in December from the prior month. Export prices are down 6.5% year-over-year.

Nonpetroleum import prices have declined for seven consecutive months (-3.9% a.r.). Curiously, U.S. export prices have also declined for seven consecutive months and non-ag export prices are down 5.9% YoY (chart from Haver Analytics).

large image

Credit and Copper May Block Rate Hikes

Barring a major upward revision in the outlook for operating profits, a steadying of financial markets may require an unambiguous shift in the likely direction of Fed policy from tightening to neutrality. Otherwise, the high-yield bond spread may remain wider than 700 bp and equity prices will struggle. The high-yield bond spread’s 738 bp average since year-end 2015 questions the rationale behind higher benchmark interest rates.

Thus far in 2016, investment-grade and high-yield bonds have moved in different directions. Unlike the -7 bp decline of the long-term Baa industrial company bond yield to 5.35%, the US composite speculative-grade bond yield jumped up by 34 bp to a recent 9.22% for its highest reading since October 2011.

However, high-yield’s prospects were more favorable in October 2011 compared to January 2016. For starters, the recent average EDF (expected default frequency) of US/Canadian non-investment-grade companies approximated 7.5%, more than doubling its 3.6% average of the three-months-ended October 2011. Moreover, the net high-yield downgrades of 2011’s second half approximated 2.8% of the number of US high-yield issuers, which was far less than the 7.9% ratio of 2015’s second half.

Also, revenues and profits both supplied stronger underpinnings for high-yield credit quality in late 2011. Yearlong 2011’s 8.3% annual surge by core business sales far surpassed 2015’s prospective 2.2% rise, where the latter will be the worst calendar-year showing by this version of business sales ex energy since 2009’s -11.8% plummet.

In addition, October 2011’s outlook for profits was brighter. Unlike recent consensus expectations of a -0.9% dip by 2015’s pretax profits from current production followed by a meek 2.8% rebound for 2016, October 2011’s consensus looked for livelier profits growth of 7.3% for 2011 and 5.0% for 2012.

image

The US composite high yield bond spread has remained above 700 bp since December 10, 2015. In all likelihood January 2016’s month-long average for high-yield spread will top 700 bp for the first time since December 2011’s 736 bp. Nevertheless, January’s spread should fall short of October 2011’s post-2009 high of 775 bp. Recently 763 bp, the high-yield spread has averaged 738 bp thus far in January.

Despite the high-yield spread’s 753 bp average of September-December 2011, the US was safely distanced from recession. After barely growing by 0.8% annualized from the second to the third quarter of 2011, real GDP proceeded to increase by 2.4% over the next four quarters. Business activity was lively enough to lower the unemployment rate from Q3-2011’s 9.0% to Q3-2012’s 8.0%.

The record suggests that a wider than 700 bp spread does not reliably indicate the nearness of a recession unless it has persisted over an extended span. For example, recessions were either impending or already underway each time the high-yield spread’s moving 12-month average first broke above 700 bp. More specifically, the high-yield spread’s moving 12-month average initially topped 700 bp for the spans-ended October 2008, February 2001, and January 1991. (…)

According to a sample that begins in late 1982, the Fed has hiked rates only once when the base metals price index’s moving 13-week was down by at least -15% year-over-year — and this one exception just occurred at the December 16, 2015 meeting of the FOMC. Despite an accompanying -26% annual plunge by the base metals price index’s moving 13-week average, the target range for fed funds was raised by 25 bp.

Moreover, the Fed had never hiked rates in the context of a wider than 650 bp high-yield bond spread until the December 16th meeting. Thus, do not be surprised if the next rate hike does not occur until industrial commodity prices stabilize convincingly and the high-yield bond spread breaks well under 700 bp. The need to resolve issues pertaining to financial market volatility and the adequacy of global growth explains why the futures market does not expect another rate hike until the June 15th meeting of the FOMC.

Industrial production down by 0.7% in euro area

In November 2015 compared with October 2015, seasonally adjusted industrial production fell by 0.7% in the euro area (EA19) and by 0.6% in the EU28, according to estimates from Eurostat, the statistical office of the European Union. In October 2015 industrial production rose by 0.8% and 0.6% respectively. In November 2015 compared with November 2014, industrial production increased by 1.1% in the euro area and by 1.4% in the EU28.

image

Nothing really positive going on in IP:image

China’s Monetary Policy on Treadmill to Nowhere

China’s central bank has one foot on the gas, but another on the brake. Little wonder it isn’t getting much traction.

Since November 2014, the People’s Bank of China has slashed interest rates six times, and cut the mandatory level of bank reserves five times. The benchmark lending rate has fallen by 1.65 percentage points. But the results so far have been unimpressive.

The latest sign was lending data released Friday. China’s banks extended just under 6 trillion yuan ($910 billion) of new loans in December. That was below expectations, and down from more than 7 trillion the previous month, even though December typically sees a seasonal uptick in lending.

Total social financing, a broader measure of credit in the economy, is also sluggish. It rose 11.8% in 2015, the slowest pace in at least a decade. Some economists argue this is an underestimate, because it excludes a new local-government bond swap program put it in place this year. The issue is disputed. But even after including this program, growth in total credit still only came to 14.3%, a slight deceleration from 2014.

Why has PBOC loosening failed to unleash credit growth? In part, because the PBOC is also tightening at the same time.

It is doing so through its massive interventions to prop up the yuan, spending around $130 billion in December alone, according to Goldman Sachs. When the PBOC spends dollars from its currency reserves to buy up yuan, this shrinks the domestic money supply. It is the opposite of the process seen in China’s boom years, when it bought up dollar inflows with newly printed yuan, adding to its reserves and domestic liquidity.

To see the effect, look at reserve money, a liability on the PBOC’s balance sheet. This is effectively the monetary base, or the amount of money supplied to banks by the PBOC.

This monetary base is shrinking. It fell from a year earlier in each of the last four months, including a 6% decline in December. These are the first such declines in at least 15 years, says Rhodium Group analyst Logan Wright. Back in 2011, when China was contending with massive inflows and buying up reserves, it was rising as fast as 33%.

So the PBOC is trying to juice liquidity with one hand, while taking money out of circulation with the other. Even more frustratingly, further PBOC loosening such as rate cuts might only add to outflow pressures, prompting more intervention.

To break the cycle, currency outflows need to stop, perhaps due to a sudden turnaround in domestic growth, or the PBOC needs to stop intervening and let the currency fall. Neither seems likely any time soon.

The FT and Bloomberg have a different view:

(…) New borrowing — including bank loans, bonds and off-balance sheet lending — totalled Rmb1.7tn ($260bn) last month, according to the central bank’s broadest gauge of credit flows to the real economy.

That is the biggest increase since January, as borrowers rushed in to take advantage of a series of interest-rate cuts and cash injections, much as US Federal Reserve easing fuelled loan growth in the US in recent years.

Corporate bonds set a monthly record, with net issuance of Rmb470bn, on the back of buoyant liquidity and falling interest rates. Equity financing was also the strongest on record at Rmb153bn in December, as regulators unfroze initial public offerings late last year amid a recovery in the stock market that has since foundered.

chart: China total financing

Global Earnings Downgrades Haven’t Been This Bad in Seven Years

(…) Analysts project a 6.7 percent contraction in fourth-quarter profits for Standard & Poor’s 500 Index members. For peers in Europe, estimates call for growth of just 2.7 percent for all of 2015, about half the pace predicted four months ago. Investors are also running for the door — they pulled about $12 billion from global stock funds last week. (…)

Thomson Reuters’ tally as of yesterday is for EPS to drop 4.9%. It was –4.7% 2 days ago and –3.7% on Dec. 31. As I said yesterday, most of the deterioration is in nergy and Financials. Q1’16 estimates are +0.8%, down from +2.3% 2 weeks ago with Energy EPS sen collapsing 60.5% vs –41.6% 2 weeks ago.

SENTIMENT WATCH
China Shares Fall Into Bear Market Shanghai Composite Index drops 20% from its recent high hit on Dec. 22
Investors pull out of US equity funds Billions of dollars withdrawn for second week amid China fears

The pace of withdrawals accelerated to $12.4bn in the week to January 13, with stock funds suffering the largest two-week period of redemptions in 10 months, according to fund flows tracked by EPFR.

Investors raced into the haven of the US dollar, with money market funds counting $24bn of inflows. Figures from Lipper showed funds investing in US government debt attracted $1.9bn — the highest level since October — in the latest week. (…)

European stock funds counted withdrawals for the first time since the start of October, while $4.5bn was pulled from US high-yield, balanced, bank loan and total return funds.

Emerging market equity funds, stung by the rout in commodity prices, saw the 11th consecutive week of redemptions.

Running of the Bears

With the S&P 500 seeing its weakest eight-day start to a year in history, you would expect to see stock market sentiment become less optimistic.  What is really surprising, though, is just how weak sentiment has become.  According to the weekly sentiment survey from AAII, bullish sentiment dropped from 22.2% down to 17.9%.  Not only is that the 45th week in the last 46 weeks where sentiment has been below 40%, but this week’s level of bullish sentiment is the lowest weekly reading in more than ten years (April 2005).  As bullish sentiment declined to the lowest levels in a decade, bearish sentiment has also been on the increase, although not to quite the same degree.  In this week’s survey from AAII, bearish sentiment increased from 38.3% up to 45.5%.  That’s a high reading, but you only have to go as far back as 2013 to find the last time bearish sentiment was higher than the current level.

10Day AD

bearish

“I Don’t Have Faith Anymore”: Frustrated Chinese Shun Stocks For Safety Of Dollars, Gold

It’s been a roller coaster year for China’s legions of semi-literate day traders who have seen the heights of feast and the depths of famine with Chinese equities over the past 12 months. Now, in the wake of more volatility, many Chinese retail investors are throwing in the towel.

Time of the bears
Doom mongers have their day in the sun in markets

(…) Mr Lapthorne acknowledged he has a curious job. “We’re paid very very well if we’re completely and utterly wrong. I suppose a bit like economists.”

Punk BHP takes $7bn hit on US shale operation Writedown adds to doubts over Anglo-Australian miner’s dividend

NEW$ & VIEW$ (14 JANUARY 2016): Oil Spills

Fed’s Beige Book Finds Modest Growth in Most Districts The U.S. economy expanded at a modest pace in most of the country into the new year, boosted by consumer spending and a tightening labor market, the Federal Reserve said.

Wages and prices remained subdued in most of the U.S. through the first week of the year, according to a survey of economic conditions, a discouraging signal for Federal Reserve officials grappling with the threat of persistently weak inflation to economic growth.

While the jobs market continued to improve moderately, wage increases were “flat to moderate, while price increases tended to be minimal” from late November through Jan. 4, the Fed’s beige book found. (…)

Wednesday’s report, based on anecdotes in the Fed’s regional survey of economic conditions, nonetheless had bright spots as the majority of the Fed’s 12 districts reported economic growth. Conditions in the New York and Kansas City districts were “essentially flat,” but contacts were “upbeat” in Boston.

Consumer spending, a mainstay of the economy, grew in most districts through the holiday season. The housing market and commercial construction improved in most areas, and loan demand grew in most districts, the Fed said.

However unseasonably warm weather caused some hiccups, prompting weaker apparel sales in a few places, and renewing downward pressure on low energy prices by increasing the sector’s already abundant inventories of oil and gas.

Auto sales “were somewhat mixed, as activity has begun to drop off from previously high levels in some districts,” the report said. The report cited lower gasoline prices as a contributing factor for auto sales in roughly half of the districts.

A strong U.S. dollar and slow growth overseas continued to stifle manufacturing activity in many areas, the report found. The sector has been hit by low commodity prices, weakness overseas and currency movements, which have curtailed demand for U.S. exports while also making imported goods less expensive. (…)

Tourism activity varied as the strong dollar made trips to the U.S. more expensive for visitors from overseas. New York reported particular weakness, with lower hotel revenue. Mild weather hurt ski resorts across the East Coast and parts of the Midwest.

Conditions on farms were generally more negative, due to weak crop and livestock prices. Drought remained a problem in some regions, while heavy rain and flooding hit harvests elsewhere. (…)

Weekly Heating Oil Price Update: Lowest Levels Since 2009

THE BIG CHINA AND OIL SPILLS
China’s Slowdown, Oil’s Slide Show Peril of Faulty Assumptions China’s waning appetite for commodities and the oil-price war are rippling through markets and supply chains in ways that are having a disproportionate impact on U.S. manufacturing and financial markets. It doesn’t necessarily spell recession, Greg Ip writes, but it shows the peril of faulty assumptions.

(…) A pronounced slowing in China’s industrial sector and a steep drop in oil prices have taken investors, business and policy makers by surprise. That doesn’t mean a crisis or recession are in the cards. But it could mean the U.S. economy and markets will take a bigger hit than the relative importance of either China or oil can explain.

Exports to China constitute less than 1% of U.S. annual gross domestic product. The U.S. is also a net importer of oil, so a fall in oil prices should be positive.

Yet, some economists estimate, in the fourth quarter of 2015 the U.S. economy grew only about 0.5% at an annual rate. (…)

The U.S. didn’t sell many commodities directly to China, but it sold things to countries that did. Their growth has slumped along with commodity prices, and capital has fled, driving down their currencies and pushing up the dollar, creating headwinds to U.S. exports.

The reversal of sentiment on oil has been even more dramatic. (…) That fueled a boom in projects premised on oil between $80 to $100, and in loans and bond issues that valued the companies’ reserves at $80 to $100 per barrel. Mr. Thomas estimates that energy accounted for two-thirds of the rise in total U.S. industrial capacity between 2009 and 2014.

(…) while U.S. auto production rose last year to meet consumer demand for gas-guzzling light trucks, Mr. Thomas notes that was more than offset by a collapse in orders for machined parts, precision tools, engines, transmissions, pumps and other “intermediate” goods for the global commodity production chain. Many companies earlier in the chain didn’t realize how exposed they were to the commodity bust.

The selloff has spilled into the financial system. Yields on bonds of energy companies have shot up and smaller banks are announcing significant reserves against lending to energy companies. The stress has spread to other borrowers: Yields on bonds issued by nonenergy companies have risen to 7.7% from 5.3% in mid-2014.

“Credit-market shocks of the sort triggered by the commodity-price collapse can prove quite damaging to broader economic conditions,” Mr. Thomas says.

How bad will it get? Because output per worker is much higher in manufacturing and mining than in services, the pullback in those sectors affects GDP more than employment. Indeed, overall job growth and demand for services so far remain buoyant.

China’s growth appears to have steadied. So absent even more contagion, the U.S. seems likely to escape a recession. Even so, this year will likely provide another object lesson in taking trends for granted.

Coincidentally, Reuters had this piece yesterday (thanks Gary):

Oil and gas production was one of the fastest-growing industries in the United States between 2009 and 2014 according to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA).

Oil production increased by more than 60 percent while natural gas production was up by more than 25 percent thanks to the shale revolution.

What is less well-known is that oil and gas production is also very energy intensive and the drilling boom contributed significantly to fuel consumption, especially diesel.

Now the drilling boom is over, lower fuel demand from oil and gas producers helps explain why diesel consumption in the United States has been unusually weak over the last 12 months.

(…) the fuel requirements of oil and gas production are significant enough that they are having a noticeable impact on consumption and prices, especially for diesel. (…)

Producing $1 worth of oil and gas required $1.58 of gross output by all domestic industries in 2014, according to the BEA (“Commodity-by-commodity total requirements” 2014).

Once all the direct and indirect effects are taken into account, U.S. oil and gas producers stimulated $1.12 worth of oil and gas demand for every $1 that they produced in 2014. (…)

During the boom, oil and gas drillers created enormous extra demand for raw materials, transport and workers, all of which in turn stimulated more oil and gas demand. Now the process has gone into reverse, worsening the slump.

CASE IN POINT:

Falling oil prices have brought widespread layoffs in the oil fields of Texas, Louisiana, Oklahoma and Pennsylvania and questions about whether once-hot local economies are retrenching for good or just hitting pause before resuming growth at a slower pace.

But the risk is acute in North Dakota, where the boom was especially strong. Oil production in the Bakken Formation, underlying the western part of the state, grew from barely a blip in 2006 to making the state the nation’s No. 2 oil producer after Texas by 2012. Thousands of workers flocked to the prairie, driving up rents and straining the resources of small communities. (…)

In December, a Moody’s report warned that the state’s economy could enter a “full-blown recession” if job losses continue. “North Dakota’s oil boom has come to an end,” wrote Moody’s economist Dan White. (…)

In recent months, Williston’s population has slipped back to about 32,000 [from 36,000 in 2014 and 12,000 in 2008], Mr. Klug said. Building permits have dropped to a third of what they were last year. Today, about $250 million of construction projects are under way, down from about $1 billion in projects three years ago.

Nick Krebsbach, manager of Eleven Restaurant & Lounge, a steak and seafood restaurant in Williston, said the long wait times and outsize tips that his staff saw during boom times are no more.

“We were busy six nights a week. Everybody was employed, and they were willing to spread it around town,” he said. “It was a whole different world than it is now.”

Mr. Krebsbach said the restaurant hasn’t had to lay off any workers but some have left because spouses lost jobs or were transferred out of state. “Now is when the real work starts and you do what you need to survive,” he said. (…)

Still, the city, which has an annual budget of about $240 million, has about $300 million in debt. Eight years ago, its budget was just $40 million.

Sales-tax revenue in Williston was down at least 35% in the quarter ended in December from a year earlier, but still above levels in 2010 and 2011.

The real-estate market has also taken a hit.(…) “We haven’t gotten a lot of foreclosures yet,” she said. (…)

In early January, there were 54 drilling rigs operating in North Dakota, down from a peak of about 200 in the spring of 2012. (…)

  • AN INSIDE VIEW:
Continental Resources CEO Sees Oil Prices Doubling by Year End Energy executive Harold Hamm sees oil prices doubling to $60 a barrel by the end of 2016, a prediction that runs counter to the many analysts who recently have been marking down their oil forecasts.

He also believes that Saudi Arabia made a “monumental mistake” in continuing to pump oil at a fast pace. The move not only depressed world prices but likely contributed to the lifting of the U.S. government’s 40-year ban on oil exports, Mr. Hamm said. (…)

Mr. Hamm, chief executive of top U.S. shale-oil producer Continental Resources Inc., believes that the current glut will ease substantially this year as U.S. shale companies ratchet down production until the market recovers. U.S. output has been falling recently but not as rapidly or by as much as many investors anticipated.

He said that will end soon. (…)

With oil prices currently covering only half the cost of industry operations, Mr. Hamm said U.S. producers are cutting output at a rate of 1.6 million barrels a year. That could quickly take the U.S. back to levels three years ago. Though companies can continue to pump at this price, they can’t afford to drill new wells, ramping down future supplies, he said.

Once supply deficits begin, they can’t reverse quickly. It could take one to two years to bring output back on line, Mr. Hamm said. With Saudi Arabia already pumping near maximum capacity, there will be little ability to make up the shortfall, he added. (…)

He added that with U.S. exports poised to gain global market share, he viewed OPEC as “almost a nonentity” that is losing its ability to dictate market prices as it has for many decades.

The Continental Resources CEO also said the end of the export ban could ease another concern: the lack of enough storage to hold all the barrels produced if supply doesn’t slow soon. Some analysts think this constraint could lead to lower oil prices as producers would look to get those barrels out the door.

Mr. Hamm said that U.S. producers shipping overseas could temporarily stow oil on board floating tankers if they run out of storage space, an option he dubbed the “blowout preventer.”

  • AN OUTSIDE VIEW:
Delayed oil projects total nears $400bn Plug pulled on equivalent of 27bn barrels amid price collapse

Oil-production-delays(…) In an authoritative study published on Thursday, the energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie says development of some 68 major projects, or 27bn barrels of oil equivalent in reserves, has been put back as companies scramble to curtail costs and protect dividend payouts.

The latest figures show that the amount of deferred capital spending on projects awaiting approval has almost doubled since June, from $200bn to $380bn, with 2.9m barrels a day of liquids production — equivalent to Kuwait’s crude output — now not due to come on stream until early in the next decade. (…)

The list has grown by a third in the last six months, with the average “break-even” price of the projects being $62 a barrel. Deepwater fields account for more than half of new deferrals, up from 17 six months ago to 29.

Canadian oil sands producers are feeling pain as bitumen — the thick, sticky substance at the center of the heated debate over TransCanada Corp.’s Keystone XL pipeline — hit a low of $8.35 on Tuesday, down from as much as $80 less than two years ago. (…)

Since most of the spending for bitumen extraction comes upfront, and thus is a sunk cost, production will continue and grow. Canada will need more pipeline capacity to transport bitumen out of Alberta by 2019, King said. (…)

Distressed debt managers ready to roll Commodity tumble impact on stock prices starts to change the game

(…) “The knife has fallen,” said David Fann, chief executive officer of TorreyCove Capital Partners, which advises investors in private equity. While much of “the reckoning” is about two years out, as many companies sold futures contracts to lock in prices for their product, “the energy opportunity is really starting to develop, finally.” (…)

The closely watched junk bond exchange traded funds, State Street’s JNK and BlackRock iShares’ HYG, have tested new lows, but are down less than 3 per cent each.

That appears to Leslie Biddle, partner at Serengeti Asset Management, as burnout in the high-yield market. Sentiment has become so bad it just can’t get much worse, she believes.

“Everyone has just gotten so pummelled about the head and face that they’re slightly immune” to further price pain, Ms Biddle says.

       

Bonds issued by BreitBurn Energy, an independent US oil and gas group, maturing in 2022 with a 7.875 per cent coupon have traded as low as 17 cents on the dollar. Denbury Resources bonds that mature in 2022 have slid to 33 cents on the dollar from 98 cents last June, yielding more than 29 per cent.

While low prices are alluring, last year’s experience has left many investors feeling it still may be too soon to step in.

“A lot of the price action is warranted,” says Putri Pascualy, a managing director at Pacific Alternative Asset Management Co. “There is real, fundamental change in the industry, both in terms of much lower prices and the fact that industry needs continued access to capital markets to function.”

Although energy and metals and mining have been the focus for distressed portfolio managers — the two sectors represent a fifth of the $1.2tn US junk bond market —, the sell-off in lower quality retail, telecom, healthcare and industrial names last year has also presented opportunities, portfolio managers say.

Richard Smith, managing director for leveraged capital markets at Mizuho says although all three leading US credit rating agencies project defaults to rise this year, many companies have already locked in funding for the near term,

Less than $1bn of subordinated, and senior-secured and -unsecured corporate debt that has fallen into distress matures in 2016, according to Standard & Poor’s. The figures climb to roughly $13bn in 2017 and $24bn in 2018 before jumping to $40bn in 2019.

While companies have space before the so-called maturity wall is hit, the size of the distressed market has surged. S&P counts 271 issuers with $233bn of debt in distress, the highest level since 2009. (…)

For some investors, the slide in bond prices in 2015 was representative of a fundamental re-pricing in high yield markets as portfolio managers have an increasingly difficult time trading in and out of junk bonds.

Bob Michele, chief investment officer of JPMorgan Asset Management, notes that investors had for a long time priced in an average of 300 basis points of “liquidity premium” to the thinly traded asset class.

“Broker dealer balance sheets are structurally smaller than they have been historically so that risk premium has to expand beyond what defaults and recoveries price in to spreads,” he says. “That seems to be the one thing that has changed. It makes sense that it has to be re-priced.”

U.S. Budget Deficit Ends Year Down 2% The U.S. budget deficit ended last year at its lowest mark since 2007, the sixth straight annual decline.

The deficit ended calendar year 2015 at $478 billion, or around 2.6% of gross domestic product, down from a year-earlier level of $488 billion, or 2.8% of GDP, the Treasury Department said Wednesday. (…)

Government spending will rise further after last fall’s bipartisan agreements between President Barack Obama and Congress that boost discretionary spending caps through September 2017 and extend a series of tax breaks for businesses and households.

Economists at Goldman Sachs estimate the deficit could rise to $650 billion, or 3.5% of GDP, in the fiscal year ending Sept. 30 and to $575 billion, or 3% of GDP, in fiscal 2017. (…)

The U.S. has added nearly $8 trillion in debt since 2007, and the nation’s debt-to-GDP ratio has doubled to around 73%, based on federal debt held by the public. Last year, debt-service costs for the U.S. government fell to 1.2% of GDP, from 1.7% in 2008. (…)

German Government Achieves ‘Historic’ Budget Surplus

Germany’s government posted a record €12.1 billion ($13.14 billion) budget surplus last year, a much needed financial boost that the country’s finance minister said will help accommodate the record influx of migrants to Europe’s largest economy. (…)

In November, the government said it has put aside an expected €6.1 billion surplus from 2015 to cover migration-related costs. In its budget plans, the government has penciled in €8 billion in total migration-related costs for 2016. Last year, nearly 1.1 million migrants arrived in Germany, nearly 1.4% of the total population. (…)

(…) Announcing the figures on Thursday, the government’s statistical office said growth in Europe’s largest economy was driven by private consumption, which rose at its strongest rate since 2000, thanks to low unemployment, wage increases and low inflation. Householders were also encouraged to spend by lower energy costs and by low interest rates on savings, which has made it less attractive to put money away for a rainy day. (…)

The statistical office said private consumption expanded by 1.9 per cent, contributing 1 percentage point to 2015 growth, while public spending added 0.5 points. Trade contributed 0.2 points, although imports expanded at a slightly higher rate than exports, which remain strong helped by a weak euro and by lower oil prices. (…)

SENTIMENT WATCH

In today’s Chart of the Day, we highlight historical bear markets for the Russell 2000 which just officially entered bear market territory today.  After running into resistance at its 50-day moving average at the end of 2015, the Russell 2000 has been in complete liquidation mode for all of 2016.  As a case in point, there has only been one day so far in 2016 where the index closed higher than its opening level.  As a result of this weakness, the index is now down more than 10% in 2016.  If you think deflation has been solely confined to commodity prices, think again.

Russell Bear

(…) “There are few people out there willing to buy the dips because everyone is scared that the selloff will be deeper the next day. And it has been. Sentiment is rock-bottom. I would sell any highs. There is definitely potential for bigger losses.” (…)

According to Bloomberg, on a share-weighted basis, S&P 500 profits are expected to have dropped by 7.2% in 4Q, while revenues are expected to fall by 3.1% This would represent the worst U.S. earnings season since 3Q 2009, and a third straight quarter of negative profit growth. It’s no longer simply a recession: as noted above, the Q4 EPS drop follows declines of 3.1% in Q3 and 1.7% in Q2. it is… whatever comes next. 

As Bloomberg adds, the main driving forces behind drop in U.S. earnings are the rise in the dollar index (thanks Fed) and the drop in average WTI oil prices. However, since more than half of all industries are about to see an EPS decline, one can’t blame either one or the other.

High five Fingers crossed Goldman Sees 11% Upside in S&P 500 After an `Emotional’ Selloff

(…)The fair value for Standard & Poor’s 500 Index is 2,100, Cohen said. The benchmark last closed above that level on December 1 and has fallen 10 percent since, after turbulence in China’s stocks and currency spurred a global market rout.

“What is happening is really very much an emotional response,” Cohen told Elliot Gotkine on Bloomberg Television. “We need to put things into perspective. Stocks are probably the best place to be.” (…)

EARNINGS WATCH

Thomson Reuters says that 23 companies or 5% of the S&P 500 have reported Q4. The beat rate is 78% with a 5% surprise factor:

image

Blending the reported with the estimates, Q4 EPS are currently seen down 4.8% from –3.7% on Jan. 1. Most od the deterioration is from Energy though Financials also retreated (b4 JPM’s results today):

image

Pre-announcements are not getting worse.

Full year EPS are now seen at $116.94 (per TR) which, at 1888, puts the trailing P/E at 16.1 and the Rule of 20 P/E at 18.1. Fair value per the Rule of 20 is 2105, right where it was in January 2015 and right where Abby Joseph Cohen sees it, not that that makes it more comfortable Winking smile.

image

Upside to fair value is 11.5%. Downside risk is to a Rule of 20 P/E of 16.3, the lows of 2011 and 2012 (1675), down 11.3%.