The enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it’s the illusion of knowledge (Stephen Hawking)

It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so (Mark Twain)

Invest with smart knowledge and objective odds

NEW$ & VIEW$ (22 SEPTEMBER 2015): Fed Confusion; China Facts.

Fed Decision to Hold Rates Steady Was a ‘Close Call’ Federal Reserve officials who have spoken following last week’s high-profile policy meeting say a rate increase this year remains in the cards.

(…) The camp advocating caution won over the Federal Open Market Committee, which voted 9-1 on Thursday to keep its benchmark rate near zero—where it has been since December 2008—to get a better read on how global economic turbulence and unsettled markets are affecting the outlook. (…)

9-1 is not really a close call!

But the real surprise is the inconsistent message from Mrs. Yellen who had promised clear communications. During her press conference last week:

  • U.S. real gross domestic product (GDP) is estimated to have expanded at a 2-1/4 percent pace in the first half of the year, a notably stronger outcome than expected in June
  • The outlook abroad appears to have become more uncertain of late.
  • the situation abroad bears close watching.
  • I do not want to overplay the implications of these recent developments,
  • which have not fundamentally altered our outlook.
  • I want to emphasize domestic developments have been strong.
  • The economy has been performing well, and we expect it to continue to do so.
  • And as I’ve said in the past, we don’t want to wait until we’ve fully met both of our objectives to begin the process of tightening policy given the lags in the operation of monetary policy.
  • The Fed should not be responding to the ups and downs of the markets and it is certainly not our policy to do so. But when there are significant financial developments, it’s incumbent on us to ask ourselves what is causing them. And of course what we can’t know for sure, it seem to us as though concerns about the global economic outlook were drivers of those financial developments. And so, they have concerned us in part because they take us to the global outlook and how that will affect us.
  • So, it’s a lot of different pieces, different cross currents, some strengthening the outlook, some creating concerns, but overall, no significant change in the economic outlook.

Yet, the FOMC cut its forecast for growth, potential growth, inflation and future fed funds rate.

Confused?

U.S. Existing Home Sales Fall Rising home prices are starting to catch up with buyers and may be leading some to put off buying for a little longer.

Existing home sales tumbled 4.8% in August to a 5.31 million seasonally adjusted annual rate, the National Association of Realtors said Monday, the steepest month-to-month decline since January, when they fell 4.9%.

Behind the decline were particularly big drops in the West and the South, two areas where prices have risen particularly sharply. In the South, where the median home price is up 6% over a year ago, month-to-month sales fell 6.6%. And in the West, where the median price rose 7.1% over the year, sales were down 7.8%.

Nationwide, the median home price hit $228,700 in August, a 4.7% increase over a year ago.

Sales of single-family homes were down 5.3% in August while sales of condominiums and co-ops dropped 1.6%. (Charts from Haver Analytics)

 large image large image

China SOE default warning highlights urgency of reform

China is bracing for its second bond default by a central government-owned company, offering one of the biggest tests yet of Beijing’s willingness to impose market discipline on lossmaking state groups.

A unit of one of the elite club of 112 big enterprises directly owned by the central government, China National Erzhong Group employed a workforce of more than 13,000 in 2012, when it had assets of Rmb25bn. But a slowing economy saddled with industry overcapacity has hobbled the heavy industry group, leading to losses of Rmb8.4bn in 2014. (…)

The company suspended trading of Rmb1bn in five-year notes sold in 2012, citing “uncertainty” about whether it could meet a Rmb56.5m ($8.9m) interest payment due next week. (…)

China’s Workers Stumble as Factories Stall As factories run out of money and construction projects idle, China sees a rise in unrest

(…) Now, many migrant workers struggle to find their footing in a downshifting economy. As factories run out of money and construction projects turn idle across China, there has been a rise in the last thing Beijing wants to see: unrest. (…)

“There’s a broad structural imbalance in China’s labor market—a shortage of low-end labor and surfeit of high-end workers,” said Peng Xizhe, professor of population and development at Fudan University in Shanghai. “In China’s job market today, we see university graduates struggling to find work, while employers are finding it hard to fill traditional blue-collar positions.” (…)

China Labour Bulletin, a Hong Kong-based watchdog, has tracked more than 1,600 labor protests and strikes in China since January, already exceeding last year’s overall tally of 1,379. (…)

The recent unrest is still far from the massive protests that swept over China in the late 1990s and early 2000s as state-owned enterprises laid off tens of millions of workers and local governments expropriated farmland around emerging cities for development.

But the rise in frequency of strikes and protests has caused concern in Beijing, which in March urged bureaucrats across the country to prioritize “harmonious labor relations.” (…)

Wages in China’s manufacturing sector now exceed comparable levels in South and Southeast Asia by as much as six times, according to the state-backed Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. Some of the work has shifted to neighboring countries like Cambodia and Vietnam, while factories are also moving deeper into the mainland, and closer to home for many migrants. (…)

Lew Says China Should Roll Out Fiscal Stimulus to Buoy Consumers
Volatility Sets In for Currencies as Fed Leaves Traders Hanging

With the central bank leaving the question of when it will move hanging over markets, its focus on economic data and international circumstances means every report will stir more volatility, according to Morgan Stanley. (…)

Traders are entering “a new era” for currency volatility, according to a Sept. 17 report from Morgan Stanley. Data dependence by the Fed, declining currency reserves and regulatory changes mean elevated price swings will characterize the U.S. tightening cycle more than in the past, the bank’s New York-based analysts Calvin Tse and Evan Brown wrote. (…)

“What markets will be focused on is not only U.S. inflation but inflation around the world and growth around the world,” Rick Rieder, chief investment officer for fixed income at BlackRock Inc., the world’s largest money manager, said at a press event in New York on Sept. 18. “You’ll see more volatility going forward in FX.” (…)

CHINA FACTS

Three alternative indicators suggest less of a deceleration in the world’s second-largest economy, and reduced risk of a hard landing. (…)

“The economy is still stable and we don’t see much volatility in consumption,” said Zhao Meng, Shanghai-based founder of UnionPay Advisors Co., which tracks bank-card spending data in real time to measure consumption patterns across various industries. “People still have the buying power.” (…)

* Rebounds at smaller businesses

Online interest in small- and medium-sized enterprises is seeing a rebound in September after recently falling to the lowest level since 2010, according to a preliminary reading of an index developed by Beijing-based Baidu Inc., which handles more than 6 billion searches a day.

Baidu tracks how often users click links to smaller companies. “Internet users’ search requests can reflect the market demand, and indicate the state of the businesses,” the company said in an e-mailed response to Bloomberg News.

* Rising prices in Alibaba shopping carts

Consumer-price inflation has picked up amid gains in food prices while a three-year streak of factory-gate deflation deepens. An index developed by Alibaba Group Holding Ltd., China’s largest e-commerce company, shows consumer prices quickening more than the government’s official reading.

Prices for all goods sold online rose 7.4 percent in August, an index developed by the Hangzhou-based company’s research arm shows.

Among 10 categories of goods Alibaba tracks, prices for a group that includes collectibles and financial services rose 14.1 percent from a year earlier, while the category for entertainment and education increased 13.7 percent. Food was 13.1 percent more expensive compared to a year earlier.

Still, there were some signs of deflation. Another indicator tracking a fixed basket of about 100,000 products showed prices for consumer staples fell compared with a year earlier, due mostly to cheaper clothing.

* Booming business at luxury hotels

An index of spending at luxury hotels in China rose to a record last month, indicating that wealthier travelers indulged themselves this summer, according to UnionPay Advisors, a research unit of China UnionPay Co., operator of the network that handles transactions for almost all of the nation’s bank cards.

Real-estate transactions have rebounded from last year’s lows, UnionPay data and official gauges show. UnionPay’s Zhao said he also sees signs of risk with spending at restaurants at about the same level as 2011, representing a sharp decrease from last year, according to his company’s data.

Based on our monthly GDP tracker, growth in July and August ran at 6.6 percent year on year — some way below the government’s 7 percent target. With a higher base to contend with, September data is unlikely to show much improvement. In the second quarter, our monthly indicator undershot the official reading as surging financial sector value added boosted growth (our monthly index doesn’t capture service sector output). In the third quarter, the collapse in the equity market means financial sector output will be more subdued. That raises the chances GDP will come in closer to the level predicted by our monthly tracker.

 
Glencore Plunges to Record Low as Mining Losses Pick Up Speed

Glencore tumbled as much as 16 percent, the most ever, and slid below 100 pence for the first time since it began trading in 2011. Anglo American Plc touched a 15-year low and Antofagasta Plc sank 7 percent. KAZ Minerals Plc, a small copper miner in Kazakhstan, lost 25 percent.

The moves come following the reduction in growth forecasts for China by the Asian Development Bank which said that countries’ declining appetite for raw materials would hurt commodity-focused export economies.

IS THE FED IN LEFT FIELD, AGAIN?

In September 2012, I wrote What If the Fed Has It All Wrong? which John Mauldin used in one of his Outside the Box posts. I questioned the wisdom of the Fed’s QE programs after QE1, arguing that income inequality would work against the desired wealth effect on economic growth.

The problem with Bernanke’s wealth effect thesis lies with the new reality in America. Income and assets have lately been so significantly redistributed that only a tiny few actually feel a wealth effect from rising equity prices. (…)

    Keep in mind that it is these wealthy people who run American corporations, keeping them lean and mean and flush with cash. They remember how profits literally disappeared in 18 months in 2007-08. They remember how financial markets totally froze in 2008. They see the humongous budget deficits and the debt piling on, and the not-so-distant day of reckoning. They realize that all the QEs in the world can’t offset inept and irresponsible politicians on either side of the Atlantic. Yet, they are the ones targeted by the so-called wealth effect!

    Call that pushing on a golden string.

    Meanwhile, the less affluent, the other 80% – some 250 million people – are little concerned by an eventual wealth effect but highly, directly, and immediately  impacted by the side effects of all these QEs, namely rising commodity prices and near-zero interest rates on their savings.

    Call that pushing on a chafed string.

These extraordinary monetary experiments have had little impact on the real economy. Three-and-a-half trillion dollars were not enough to lift the economy sufficiently to allow the Fed to normalize interest rates six years after. In reality, the U.S. economy never regained any sustained momentum with growth averaging a paltry 2.1% since 2010 or 1.3% per capita, and staying close to recession all the while, forcing the Fed to keep the financial heroin flowing..

image

And now, after warning us for months that domestic conditions were just about getting right to begin raising rates off their zero floor, Mrs. Yellen spent the better part of her press conference last week talking about “global economic and financial developments” and the damage these could do to U.S. growth and inflation.

This “data dependant” group has decided to stand pat in spite of all these positive developments since the FOMC meeting of July 28-29:

  • The number of job openings rose 21.7% YoY in July to 5.753 million.
  • The average job gain over the past three months was 221,000, a slowdown from the July three-month average of 250,000, but still a healthy pace.The latest number includes August’s 173,000 new jobs but everybody knows that August data are often revised upwards. Over the past five years, revisions have added an average 79,000 jobs to the initial August readings.
  • Full-time employment is up by 1 million in the past 2 months.
  • The unemployment rate declined to 5.1% in August from 5.3%, the lowest level since 2008. It troughed at lower levels during the last two bubble cycles but it had troughed at 5.8% in 1979 and 5.2% in 1989.
  • New jobless claims are at a 40-year cyclical low. Adjusted for the diminished labor force, claims are at a record low, suggesting very limited immediate labor slack.
  • Average weekly hours for all private employees at 34.6 are back at their 2007 peak level.
  • Average hourly earnings of private employees rose 0.4% MoM in August following +0.3% in July, a 4.3% annualized growth rate. They are up 2.4% YoY after averaging +1.9% during the first 7 months.
  • Given the growth in hours, wages and employment, the income proxy for August is in the +4.5-5.0% range.
  • Nominal personal disposable income rose 0.5% MoM in July, bettering the previous 3 consecutive 0.4% gains. The annualized rate since March is +5.2%, +3.0% in real terms (+3.6% in the last two months).
  • Nominal expenditures are also up 5.2% annualized since March while real expenditures are up 2.7% annualized.
  • “Core” retail sales rose 0.4% in August and are up at a 5.3% annualized rate in the last 3 months.
  • Car sales reached an annualized pace of 17.8 million in August, back to their previous cyclical peaks. Sales of light trucks and SUVs now substantially exceed autos sales.
  • Housing starts were up 15.9% in August and their last 3-month average is 16.5% above the 2014 average.
  • Existing home sales are up 10.3% YoY and reached pre-recession levels in July.
  • U.S. construction spending is up 13.9% YoY in July and at a 15.6% annualized rate in the last 3 months. Private construction is even stronger: +17.5% YoY and +15.5% annualized.
  • Orders for non-defense capital goods ex-aircraft jumped 2.2% MoM in July after +1.4% in June.

In brief, the consumer side of the U.S. economy, which is nearly 70% of GDP, is strong and strengthening on solid fundamentals. Economic drivers such as autos, housing, construction and capex are also contributing. While QEs boosted asset values for the wealthiest Americans, lower commodity prices and a strong U.S. dollar are boosting the purchasing power of ordinary people. And being true Americans, they are now spending the windfall.

Yes, U.S. manufacturing is weak as U.S. exports are impacted by the strong dollar and domestic manufacturers struggle against import competition and price deflation. But there’s nothing new there, is there?

image

Manufacturing employs but 8.9% of all American non-farm workers against 86% for the Services sector. New manufacturing jobs total 28,000 so far in 2015. New service-providing jobs amount to 1.65 million. Goods-producing industries contributed 0.5% to GDP growth in 2013-14, less than one-third the 1.6% contribution from services-producing industries. Hourly earnings in services have increased at an annualized rate of 2.9% so far in 2015, reaching $24.75/hour in August. Manufacturing wages have also risen at a 2.9% rate this year and are now $25.33, only 2.3% higher than services wages (+7.7% in 2006).

EMPLOYMENT: SERVICESimage

THE DYNAMICS OF COMMODITY DEFLATION

So when Mrs. Yellen spends the better part of her press conference talking about external risks to the U.S. economy, her focus is dangerously misplaced. Furthermore, she and her fellow FOMC members fail to grab the dynamics of commodity deflation.

During the last 20 months, there have been extraordinary declines in prices of a large variety of commodities. To wit:

  • image_thumb2Oil (Nymex): –63% since June 2014
  • Copper: –33% since December 2013
  • Aluminum: –29% since August 2014
  • Iron Ore: –60% since December 2013
  • Nickel: –48% since March 2014
  • Corn: –29% since April 2014
  • Coffee: –45% since October 2014
  • Wheat: –30% since April 2014
  • Soybeans: –40% since April 2014
  • Sugar: –32% since May 2014
  • Cotton: –30% since February 2014

    Such widespread and significant price declines cannot be only the result of a general supply glut. This is not only China slowing given the large number of food commodities in sharp declines. It is also not simply a USD reaction since the dollar really began to spike late in 2014. Rather, it is symptomatic of a sustained, general slowdown in global demand.

    World Bank data show that global GDP growth slowed from the 4% range before the financial crisis to 2.3% on average between 2011 and 2014 and is expected to be less than 2.8% in 2015.

    image_thumbHigh-income countries are expected to grow by 2 percent in 2015 and 2.3 percent in 2016–17.

    Developing countries are facing two transitions, as they adjust to prospects of low commodity prices over the medium-term and tighter financial conditions ahead. Oil prices appear to have found some support, upon evidence of a sharp decrease in unconventional oil production capacity in the United States, but are likely to remain low. Other commodity prices continue to be soft, on weak demand as well as ample supplies. As a result, in commodity exporting countries, especially those with limited reserve and fiscal buffers, activity has slowed more than anticipated, currencies have weakened, and domestic and external vulnerabilities have grown. (…)

    Compared with 2014, growth in developing countries is expected to slow to 4.4 percent in 2015, 0.4 percentage point less than anticipated in January, before rising to 5.3 percent in 2016–17. Growth prospects for low-income countries (LICs) remain robust, above 6 percent in 2015–17.

    In a second transition, developing countries will be at heightened risk of depreciation amid a gradual tightening of financial conditions, albeit from very accommodative levels, and moderating capital flows.

    The World Bank is normally sanguine in its forecasts. The reality is that the widespread collapse in commodity prices coupled with the strong USD is crippling most developing countries without a commensurate and simultaneous offsetting stimulation of demand in developed countries.

    On Aug. 26, we learned that

    Household spending on consumption fell more than 4% year-over-year in the three months ended June in Indonesia and Malaysia, two of Southeast Asia’s linchpin economies, according to statistics compiled by CEIC Data. In Thailand, growth in consumer spending slowed to 1.3% year-over-year in the second quarter from 4% in the first.

    High-frequency data show retail sales in Indonesia fell 5.3% year-over-year. Sales fell more than 13% in Singapore, a typically volatile market, its fourth straight month of contraction.

    Meanwhile, farmers in Asia have been particularly hard hit by falling commodities prices and have less purchasing power as a result. (WSJ)

    On August 31, we also learned that Thailand’s private consumption index fell 2.1% from a year earlier in July, widening from a revised 0.1% on-year drop in June.

    On the other side of the globe, the same week, we learned that

    U.S. net farm income will drop to $58.3 billion from $91.1 billion in 2014, marking the largest percentage decline since 1983, including when figures are adjusted for inflation. The projected decrease would mark the second consecutive drop after incomes reached nominal record highs in 2013, according to the USDA.

    Global food deflation adds to the impact that low oil prices are having on state producers from Russia, to Brazil, to Canada’s Alberta and to the U.S. producing states where some 33% of the American population is directly impacted by falling commodity prices.

    In real life, commodity producers are quick to retrench as soon as they see lower prices in futures markets. Anticipating the inevitable drop in their revenues, they adapt their consumption patterns well before their revenues actually decline.

    On the other hand, commodity consumers do not adjust their consumption so rapidly. For starters, it often takes a while before lower commodity prices find their way to the final products. Secondly, people will often wait and see if the lower prices have some permanency before actually taking full advantage of their newly found purchasing power.

    We are currently going through the severe demand slowdown in producing regions, awaiting the full effect on demand from commodity consumers.

    The hope is that this dislocation between demand from producing (mainly developing) countries and demand from consuming (mainly developed) countries does not last much longer and that consumers in richer developed countries start using their enhanced purchasing power to boost consumption.

    CONSUMERS TO THE RESCUE

    Real retail sales in the U.S. nosedived 13% during the financial crisis and never really closed the trend gap.

    image_thumb21

    Income growth was certainly restrained in the U.S. since the financial crisis but the main reason for the continued gap between trend lines stems from the jump in savings as consumers took time to restore their balance sheet.

    image_thumb7

    The deleveraging process is likely coming to an end. Declining debt levels combined with low interest rates have brought household debt servicing to an historical low of 10%. Given the sustained growth in employment and rising consumer confidence, we can assume that growth in consumer spending will be more closely aligned with income growth and may, in fact, rise faster in coming years as the savings rate declines to the 4% range from its current 5%.

     image_thumb10 image_thumb11

    As lower commodity prices work their way through the manufacturing and distribution processes, we can also expect that goods deflation will continue for a while. The PCE deflator for consumer expenditures is up 0.3% YoY in the first 7 months of 2015, down from +2.0% in Q314 and +1.1% in Q414. Since January, Services inflation has been +1.9% but Goods inflation has been –3.0%, including –2.2% for Durable Goods which are not directly oil-sensitive.

    The U.S. PPI for finished goods has been deflating since July 2014 and has been negative YoY since November 2014. Import prices are also deflating on the strength of the USD. Import prices for all commodities ex-petroleum are down 4.0% annualized so far in 2015. Import prices for consumer goods excluding automotives are down 1.2% YoY in August, having declined sequentially in 8 of the last 11 months and at a 1.5% annualized rate since February. Automotive prices have also been deflating in 2015 at a 2.1% a.r..

     image_thumb211

    A similar deflation pattern is visible in most of the consuming OECD countries:

    image_thumb41

    As we enter the all-important stretch from back-to-school to Christmas, the U.S. consumer seems poised to accelerate its spending thanks to its increased purchasing power, a much improved balance sheet and high confidence as employment growth continues. European consumers are also beginning to spend. Real retail sales have been accelerating since October 2014 reaching +2.0% YoY last May until the Greek uncertainty caused a small setback in June-July. July real sales were up 3.5% YoY in Germany (+4.5% a.r. in last 4 months) , 3.3% in Spain (+5.1%) and 1.6% in France (+2.7%).

    image

    Given the on-going slowdown in China and the supply excesses engineered by low cost money since 2010, commodity prices are unlikely to stage a sharp rebound anytime soon. Commodity producers are thus likely to endure slow growth for a while, at least until consuming economies really accelerate their consumption.

    This is where lies the risk for the Fed and financial markets. Misreading the transition between commodity-producing and commodity-consuming regions can lead to over-reacting to external challenges and under-estimating domestic strength.

    U.S. real retail sales were up a seemingly low 2.2% YoY in August. Yet, core retail sales in July-August are up at over a 6% annual rate. We are entering the all important back-to-school to Christmas season with the consumer fired up to spend on discretionary goods and services. Were that to happen, the current inventory glut in the economy would be quickly eliminated, triggering renewed manufacturing production when domestic labor supply is very tight.

    The Fed might then find itself well behind the curve and pain to steer, let alone stop, this big ship then going at cruising speed.

    In her press conference following the latest FOMC meeting, Mrs. Yellen said:

    While we still expect that the downward pressure on inflation from these factors will fade over time, recent global economic and financial developments are likely to put further downward pressure on inflation in the near term.

    (…) the Committee anticipates that inflation will remain quite low in the coming months.

    Trivia question: What is the annualized U.S. inflation since January 2015:

    • Headline CPI: +2.4% (-2.5% in the 6 months previous)
    • Core CPI: +2.0% (+1.4%)
    • Headline PCE deflator: +2.1% (-0.4%)
    • Core PCE deflator: +1.7% (+1.0%)

    We are thus nowhere near deflation even with goods deflation. In fact, goods prices are +2.4% annualized since February even though they are –2.7% YoY. If it were not for Energy goods and services which are down –15.7% YoY, headline inflation would be much higher. But energy goods and services prices have been exploding at a 16.2% annualized rate since February!

    So the Committee, which “continues to monitor inflation developments closely” must be looking at things differently…

    What are the odds that 3-6 months from now we find the U.S. economy expanding north of 3% with accelerating wages and inflation above 2%? The FOMC would put these odds near current Fed fund rates. I would not.