The enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it’s the illusion of knowledge (Stephen Hawking)

It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so (Mark Twain)

Invest with smart knowledge and objective odds

NEW$ & VIEW$ (8 OCTOBER 2015): China’s Slowdown Near End?

OECD Leading Indicators Point to Continued Slowdowns

The Paris-based research body said its gauges of future economic activity—which are based on information available for August—point to slowdowns in the U.S., China and Japan, as well as the U.K. and Canada. (…)

The most pressing concern for policy makers is the outlook for the Chinese economy, amid signs that its slowdown may turn out to be sharper than expected. The OECD’s leading indicator for the world’s second-largest economy fell again in August, to 97.2 from 97.6. (…)

The leading indicators suggest things won’t get any worse for Brazil and Russia, but neither is growth set to pick up. The OECD’s leading indicators continued to suggest India will be the main exception, with growth set to accelerate. (…)

But the OECD’s leading indicators suggest the eurozone economy will avoid a slowdown, and signal a pickup in France and Italy, both of which have lagged behind other members of the currency area.

image

image

CHINA WATCH
Pointing up China jumps off its own fiscal slide

Noted China bear Zhiwei Zhang, once of Nomura and now at Deutsche, is talking up China’s near-term economic prospects.

The reason? He thinks its fiscal slide — predicated on falling land sales which accounted for 22 per cent of general government revenues in 2014 — has come to an end. (…)

From Zhang on Thursday, with our emphasis:

We believe the fiscal slide is now coming to its end, because the recovery of land sales seems to have firmed up and gathered momentum in recent months.

While growth of land sales had hit the bottom in 2014Q4, the recovery did not show much momentum until May/June 2015. For instance, the yoy growth in value terms was still at -36% in April, but it turned positive in July to 3% (Figure 5). The preliminary data of September now shows a yoy growth of 30%, which could be even higher due to the lag in land sales reporting. (…)

Apart from a cyclical aspect (land sales were low for a long time and thus are due a rebound, essentially) Zhang says the boost to land sales is mostly down to China’s recent bout of fiscal easing. That and the stock market:

On monetary front, with 5 interest rate cuts (1.25 pp in total) and 4 general RRR cuts (2.5 pp in total) within 12 months’ time, corporate financing costs have come down significantly. For instance, the RMB5 billion bonds issued by China Vanke in Sep 2015 carried a face interest of only 3.5%, while a year ago the rates on such corporate bonds were mostly in the range of 5% to 10%. The recent surge of bond issuance, especially by property developers, shows that the corporates are indeed trying to take advantage of current low cost environment. On fiscal policies, the shift from tightening to stimulus, in particular the loosening of financing restrictions on LGFVs, also played a role. (…)

The poor equity market performance is perhaps another contributing factor. Shanghai and Shenzhen stock markets experienced one of their worst quarters in 2015Q3 by dropping 28.6% and 30.3%, respectively. This has made property investment a more attractive alternative, which in turn helped to restore property developers’ interest in purchasing lands.

(…) If investment can rebound on the back of lift in land sales then GDP will do so too. For a while, at least. (…)

A final chunk from Zhang to close:

Recovery of land sales and loosened fiscal stance will help to boost government spending in 2015H2. For instance, there have been clear indications of fiscal expansion following the policy u-turn in May. Growth of budgetary expenditure averaged 25% yoy in July and August, more than doubling the 11.8% in 2015H1. Total government expenditure, including that by government funds, also accelerated. The extrapolated yoy growth for Q3 based on July and August data is 11.9%, much faster than the 3.4% in H1 (-0.2% in Q1 and 6.2% in Q2). Another indication of fiscal expansion is the spike of funds available for investment from the state budget, whose yoy growth was only 9% in May, but then jumped to 17%, 29% and 34% in June, July and August, respectively.

There are other indications of a likely pickup in investment as well, such as the strong recovery of property sales and the pickup of investment amounts for both projects under constructions and newly started projects (…).(…)

Together these indications have reinforced our view that, led by accelerated government spending and an investment recovery, there will be a moderate growth rebound in Q4 from 7.0% yoy in Q3 and Q2 to 7.2%, with 7.0% full year growth for 2015.

The momentum will likely carry on to 2016Q1, but growth beyond that remains uncertain. Our baseline case is that growth returns to a downward trend, with the full year GDP growth dropping modestly to 6.7% in 2016 from 7% in 2015. The key underlying assumption is that the government will be willing to tolerate the slowdown and refrain from further fiscal and monetary stimulus once growth rebounds in Q4. The Communist Party Plenum in October and the Central Economic Working Conference in December will likely shed more light on policy stance in 2016. (…)

Interestingly, CEBM Research’s October survey confirms the pick up in land sales:

Land sales activity showed continued signs of improvement in September, especially in 1st and 2nd tier cities. Local governments have boosted efforts to sell land in response to better housing sales in prior months. In addition, after many months of refraining from restocking land banks some developers have started to restock.

However, that was the only positive from the recent survey:

  • Steel: Order activity remains low. A broad-based decline in demand was observed in September. Respondents reported that demand from key sectors such as auto manufacturing, real estate, machinery equipment and shipbuilding was stagnant or in some cases contracted, putting downward pressure on effective contract pricing for steel products. Given the anemic domestic demand situation, steel export volume remained at a healthy level in September.
  • Cement: In some regions, such as Southern China, respondents reported a pickup in construction activity. Respondents expect stable or slightly better sales activity in October as the market enters a traditional peak sales season. September also saw a coordinated price hike by producers.
  • Property: Survey respondents reported that transaction volume during September (traditionally a peak month for property sales) fell flat.
  • Exports: Container Freight Exporters: Anticipated Surge in End-of- Month Shipments Fails to Materialize; October Looking Weak,
Americans spend savings from cheap petrol Research clashes with reports that consumers were paying down debt

New analysis of the spending patterns of 25m people shows that households spent about 80 per cent of the windfall they received as a result of lower fuel prices — higher than suggested by some early government estimates.

The data from the JPMorgan Chase Institute suggests that the spending kick from lower gas prices has already been significant in a wide range of categories including dining out, entertainment and purchases of electronics and appliances — and that a rise in the price of oil could deliver a palpable blow to these areas.

“Consumers report that they are using their gains at the pump to pay down debts and save. Our data show they are spending most of them,” said the report, published on Thursday. (…)

Nerd smile Americans typically save 4-5% of their income so saving 20% of the oil windfall is significant.

BTW: Oct 7 (NYT) — Energy Department predicts lower winter fuel bills by roughly 18%

U.S. Consumers Show Signs of Caution with Debt Americans added to their debt at a slower pace in August—with outstanding consumer credit rising 5.6% versus July’s 6.6% increase—suggesting some caution on the part of consumers.

Outstanding consumer credit, a reflection of all debt besides mortgages, rose $16 billion or at a 5.6% annual rate in August, the Federal Reserve said Wednesday. That’s less than in July, when it increased at an annual rate of 6.6%, a slight downward revision from the initial estimate of 6.7%. In June, it rose at an annual rate of 9.6%.

Revolving credit, mostly credit cards, rose at an annual rate of 5.3%, a bit less than in July, when it rose at a downwardly revised annual rate of 5.5%.

Nonrevolving credit, made up largely of auto or student loans, rose at an annual rate of 5.7%, its lowest percentage increase since July 2012. (Charts from Haver Analytics)

 large image large image
UAW Strike Averted at Fiat Chrysler

The United Auto Workers said shortly after midnight Thursday that it reached a revised deal with Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV that secures “significant gains” for its members,averting a strike that would have shut down production at U.S. plants and sent thousands of workers to the picket line.

The UAW didn’t offer any further details on the proposed deal, but in a statement, UAW President Dennis Williams says the new accord “addresses our members’ principal concerns about their jobs and their futures.”

More signs that recent employment data looked strange:

U.S. Job Creation Index Steady at Seven-Year High

Gallup’s U.S. Job Creation Index registered +32 in September for the fifth consecutive month. This is the highest score Gallup has recorded since it began measuring employees’ perceptions of job creation at their workplaces in early 2008.

SeptemberJobCreation1

EM slowdown hits German exports Data show sharpest monthly fall since the financial crisis

Exports in August were 5.2 per cent lower than July, their sharpest monthly fall since the financial crisis, according to Germany’s national statistics office. Imports also fell 3.1 per cent. (…)

Exports were up 5 per cent in comparison with August 2014, while imports were 4 per cent higher. Exports to non-EU countries climbed fastest, rising 6.8 per cent, while sales to EU member states were up 3.5 per cent. (…)

As Europe’s biggest exporter, Germany — which sends 6.5 per cent of its exports to China — is particularly exposed to such trends, and German companies have been warning for a while of a Chinese slowdown. (…)

Thursday’s export statistics predate the emissions-rigging scandal that has engulfed Volkswagen, Germany’s largest carmaker.

High five From Markit’s Germany Manufacturing PMI:

German manufacturing companies reported a further improvement in operating conditions in September. Despite falling from 53.3 in August to 52.3, the average PMI reading for the third quarter (52.5) was the best in over a year.

September data signalled a further solid rise in new business placed with German manufacturers. The rate of new order growth eased slightly since August, but was nevertheless the second-strongest in 17 months. New export business also increased further during the month, with companies commenting on the weak euro and improved demand from the US.

EARNINGS WATCH

The Q3’15 earnings season officially kicks off this afternoon with Alcoa. But the season has actually started with 17 off-fiscal companies having reported as of Oct. 2nd. For what it is worth, 14 beat and 2 missed.

Zacks Research tallies all NYSE companies

Deutsche Bank Sees Big Loss on Write-Down in Corporate Banking Deutsche Bank warned it will take a $6.5 billion charge on assets in its investment and retail- and private-banking operations for the third quarter and said it could cut its dividend.

Germany’s largest bank said the bulk of the write-downs were sparked by tougher regulatory requirements, which are driving down the value of its investment-banking business and other assets.

For Deutsche Bank, constraints on earnings coupled with regulators’ demands that the bank set aside more capital mean that its investment bank—notably including the Bankers Trust business it bought in 1999—isn’t expected to generate the profits it had in the past.

Also included are charges related to its Postbank retail unit, which Deutsche Bank plans to shed. The bank also set aside an additional €1.2 billion for legal reserves. (…)

As part of companywide cost cutting and a realignment of its businesses, Deutsche Bank said its management board will recommend “a reduction or possible elimination” of its common-share dividend for 2015. The company has paid a dividend of €0.75 a share the past six years. (…)

Warning for M&A: Another Debt Deal Struggles

Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. are struggling to sell $1.2 billion of loans backing the leveraged buyout of online clothing retailer FullBeauty Brands, investors said, the latest sign that global economic turmoil has forced a broad reassessment of risk.

The setback is the latest for firms seeking to raise funds in corporate-debt markets, as prices have declined recently and several large deals have had to be scaled back. (…)

NEW$ & VIEW$ (7 OCTOBER 2015): Growth Issues; China Issues; Oil Issues; Earnings Issues…

IMF Lowers Global Outlook Agency cuts 2015 global growth view to 3.1% from its previous forecast of 3.3%

(…) The IMF cut its forecast for emerging markets to 4% this year, down 0.2 percentage point from its last update in July. That marks the fifth consecutive year of declining growth and a level nearly half the rate the IMF recorded six years ago.

Modest growth in the U.S. and a meager recovery in the eurozone, meanwhile, haven’t been able to offset falling output in emerging markets. Souring emerging-market prospects also are muting next year’s rebound: The IMF reduced its prediction for global growth in 2016 by the same amount to 3.6%. (…)

The fund said there’s a 50% chance the global growth rate will fall below 3% next year, a level it has, in the past, said is “equivalent to a global recession.” (…)

The IMF kept its forecast for China’s growth to slow to 6.3% in 2016 from 6.8% this year as fund officials say fears of a hard landing are overblown. A booming services sector appears to be offsetting a decline in manufacturing as the country transitions to a new growth model more reliant on domestic consumption, Mr. Obstfeld said. (…)

Calm Down: The Case for a Better Global Growth Outlook

(…) Just hours after Obstfeld spoke, Citigroup Inc. economists were warning that “continued sub-par growth is likely to put the global economy back into recession.” They’ve already penciled in a 55 percent probability of such an event in the next couple of years.

The relatively good news for finance ministers and central bankers gathering in Lima for the IMF’s annual meetings is that most economists are siding with Obstfeld and advising investors not to panic about the economic outlook.

“We are struck by the negative spin many commentators are putting on recent developments,” Ethan Harris, co-head of global economics research at Bank of America Corp., said in an report to clients last week.

His review of past worldwide recessions finds they’ve been caused by three things, none of which are a present danger. Central banks aren’t fighting inflation, commodity prices aren’t surging and the U.S. economy isn’t facing serious problems.

The global economy was previously able to withstand the Latin American banking crisis of the 1980s, currency turmoil in Europe and Mexico in the early 1990s and Europe’s more recent fiscal woes, Harris said as he noted that “history is on our side.”

What about contemporary risks such as the slump in emerging markets in a world they hold greater sway, or a lack of room for central banks to inject more stimulus?

While developing nations now account for about 35 percent of global gross domestic product, exclude China and they’re still on course to grow 2.5 percent this year, according to BofA. Even though growth has disappointed in such economies every year since 2011, the world has plowed on.

As for China, Alan Higgins, U.K. chief investment officer at Coutts & Co., says the nation’s woes aren’t contagious given that its exports only contribute about 3 percent to global GDP, and about half of those are components that the receiving country ships back out again in finished products. Beijing is also stepping up its response, cutting taxes on vehicle purchases and reducing the minimum down payments for first-time home buyers.

There is still momentum in developed markets. Fiscal austerity is showing signs of fading, Greece’s problems are now ring-fenced, banks are lending more and the slide in commodities should boost consumption and investment. (…)

Add that China has adopted 20 fiscal stimulus measures in September alone and that the Party’s 5th Plenum meeting will be held in 2 weeks. In China, the Party decides and dictates. The Government then executes as directed. Employment conditions are worsening in China which must unnerve Beijing more and more. More stimulus is likely on te way.

Then there are the lags between the negative effects of lower commodity prices on producing countries and their positive impacts on consuming countries as I argued in IS THE FED IN LEFT FIELD, AGAIN? As this Markit PMI chart shows, DM economies are performing pretty well.

image

Within the U.S. economy, the much wider-than-expected trade gap in August suggests that real net exports should weigh down 3Q real GDP by -0.5 percentage point. Yet, Evercore ISI says that final domestic demand appears robust in 3Q, probably advancing over 4.0%. 

Willem Buiter, chief economist at Citigroup, Tobias Levkovich, chief U.S. equity strategist at Citigroup, and Ed Morse, head of commodity research at Citigroup, examine the global economy, the impact of China’s economic slowdown, lower commodity prices and the economic struggle created by zero interest rates. They speak on “Bloomberg Surveillance.”

Pointing up Mortgage Applications “Up Sharply”, Purchase Applications up 49% YoY

The seasonally adjusted Purchase Index increased 27 percent from one week earlier. The unadjusted Purchase Index increased 27 percent compared with the previous week and was 49 percent higher than the same week one year ago. (…)

This surge was partially related to applications being filed before the TILA-RESPA regulatory change, so I expect applications to decline significant in the next survey.

The average contract interest rate for 30-year fixed-rate mortgages with conforming loan balances ($417,000 or less) decreased to 3.99 percent, the lowest level since May 2015, from 4.08 percent, with points increasing to 0.46 from 0.45 (including the origination fee) for 80 percent loan-to-value ratio (LTV) loans.

image

To be watched closely. I can understand the rush to beat a regulatory change on refinancing but purchasing implies a real transaction. The Purchase Index has been stuck in a narrow channel since 2010.

image

U.S. Trade Deficit Deepens Unexpectedly

The U.S. foreign trade deficit in goods and services during August increased to $48.3 billion from $41.8 billion in July, revised from $41.9 billion. A deficit of $43.0 billion had been expected in the Action Economics Forecast Survey. Exports declined 2.0% (-6.2% y/y) and imports rose 1.2% (-2.2 %y/y). In constant dollars, the trade deficit in goods deepened to $63.4 billion from $56.1 billion. Real exports of goods fell 1.5% (-2.5% y/y) and reversed a 1.2% July surge while real goods imports increased 3.1% (6.8% y/y) after a 0.8% dip.

The 2.0% decline in exports reflected a 3.1% drop in goods, off 10.5% y/y. In constant dollars, goods exports fell 1.5% (-2.5% y/y) during August as auto exports declined 3.8% (-4.5% y/y) following a 5.0% gain. Nonauto consumer goods exports fell 3.0% (-4.0% y/y) and added to a 2.5% fall. Industrial supplies & materials exports were off 2.0% (-3.2% y/y), reversing a 2.5% increase. Capital goods exports gained 0.5% for a second straight month (-4.8% y/y). Foods, feeds & beverages exports also increased 0.5% (11.3% y/y) following two months of roughly 1.6% decline. Services exports improved 0.6% (2.5% y/y) as travel exports gained 0.8% (1.7% y/y).

Imports increased 1.2% during August (-2.2% y/y) and reversed a 1.0% decline during July. In constant dollars, nonpetroleum goods imports rose 3.5% (7.0% y/y) after a 1.0% drop. Nonauto consumer goods imports jumped 8.5% (14.2 % y/y) and reversed July’s 4.9% decline. Capital goods imports increased 2.5% (1.4% y/y) following a 0.6% improvement. Foods, feeds & beverages imports gained 1.3% (4.2% y/y) after a 0.7% dip. Industrial supplies & materials imports eased 0.4% (+0.7% y/y) after a 1.4% jump and automotive vehicles & parts imports fell 1.0% (+10.3% y/y), offsetting a 1.3% increase. Imports of services improved 0.7% (3.7% y/y) as travel imports increased 1.5% (10.8% y/y).

large image

Once the Biggest Buyer, China Starts Dumping U.S. Government Debt Central banks are selling U.S. government bonds at the fastest pace on record, the most dramatic shift in the $12.8 trillion Treasury market since the financial crisis.

Foreign official net sales of U.S. Treasury debt maturing in at least a year hit $123 billion in the 12 months ended in July, according to Torsten Slok, chief international economist at Deutsche Bank Securities, the biggest decline since data started in 1978. A year earlier, foreign central banks purchased $27 billion of U.S. notes and bonds.

(…) the PBOC has been buying yuan and selling dollars to prevent the yuan from weakening beyond around 6.40 per dollar.

Internal estimates at the PBOC show that it spent between $120 billion and $130 billion in August alone in bolstering the yuan’s value, according to people close to the central bank.

China isn’t alone. Russia’s holdings of all U.S. Treasury debt fell by $32.8 billion in the year ended in July, according to the latest data available from the U.S. Treasury. Taiwan’s holdings dropped by $6.8 billion. Norway, a developed nation hit by the oil-price decline, reduced its Treasury holdings by $18.3 billion.

Some other central banks increased holdings. India increased its Treasury debt holdings to $116.3 billion at the end of July 2015 from $79.7 billion a year ago. The Federal Reserve held $2.45 trillion of Treasury debt at the end of September and isn’t expected to sell U.S. debt soon.

Traders said China’s selling has been a factor in why 10-year Treasury yields have remained near 2% as stock and commodity markets tumbled in recent months. The yield fell as low as 1.6% before the so-called taper tantrum in mid-2013 as the Fed prepared to end monthly bond purchases. (…)

High five In the 12 months to July, foreign private investors bought long-term Treasury debt at the fastest pace in more than three years.

U.S. bond mutual funds and exchange-traded funds targeting U.S. government debt have attracted $20.4 billion net cash this year through the end of September, poised for the biggest calendar-year inflow since 2009, according to fund tracker Lipper. (…)

China and the ‘Impossible Trinity’

When Chinese markets reopen on Thursday following an extended holiday, investors will be watching for the next phase of the country’s wrestling match with the “impossible trinity.”

China basically bowed to the impossible trinity when it devalued the yuan on Aug. 11. The act was an acknowledgment of the challenge of maintaining a flexible monetary policy, a fixed exchange rate and freely flowing capital at the same time. The term, which is used interchangeably with the “unholy trinity” and the “trilemma,” was popularized by economists Robert Mundell and Marcus Fleming in the 1960s.

It helps explain why China isn’t lowering interest rates further, even amid signs of continued economic softness. If it did, the flow of capital out of the country would pick up. Worries about flight already have prompted China to resort to some capital controls.

And although the yuan, also known as the renminbi, has appreciated by 0.6% against the dollar since tumbling on Aug. 11, many analysts say further currency weakness is inevitable.

Pointing up “The price that China is paying for maintaining renminbi stability is they have not been able to ease monetary policy more aggressively,” said David Woo, head of global rates and currencies research at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. “There’s a pretty good chance they’ll have to let the renminbi go, make it a free-floating currency.”

Most developed economies focus on two aspects of the trinity: monetary policy and open borders when it comes to capital. The exchange rate is allowed to float.

China’s battle with the “unholy trinity” has rattled financial markets, adding to the nervousness about the country’s economic slowdown.

Past reckonings with the trilemma have resulted in sharp currency devaluations as central banks were forced to allow currencies to float. In 1994, Mexico’s central bank severed the peso’s peg to the dollar after digging deep into its foreign-exchange reserves to support the currency, which was under pressure from capital flight sparked in part by monetary easing.

The unholy trinity also played a role in the Asian financial crisis in 1997-1998. In Thailand, where the crisis began, the government held rates steady and instituted some capital controls to stop money from leaving the country. The Bank of Thailand quickly burned through its foreign-currency reserves in supporting the baht, and its peg to the dollar eventually collapsed in July 1997.

Last month, the People’s Bank of China required that banks trading currency forward contracts denominated in dollars must deposit 20% of their sales at the central bank starting on Oct. 15, a move designed to stabilize the renminbi. In addition, the PBOC took steps on Sept. 1 to stem the flow of money leaving the country by having large lenders monitor Chinese corporations to ensure they limit their currency exchanges to paying for imports or approved foreign investments.

In August, China cut interest rates for the fifth time since November. Any further easing would exert more downward pressure on the renminbi—which is still loosely pegged to the dollar after the Aug. 11 changes—and could spark another wave of capital flight, especially if the Federal Reserve lifts interest rates in the U.S., analysts say.

After the devaluation, China also used its massive foreign-exchange reserves to stabilize the currency. In August, the country’s reserves fell by a record $93.9 billion. (…)

Oil jumps $2, breaks trading range as supply seen ebbing

(…) Global oil demand will grow by the most in six years in 2016 while non-OPEC supply stalls, the EIA said in its monthly report on Tuesday that suggested a surplus of crude is easing more quickly than expected.

Total world supply is expected to rise to 95.98 million barrels a day in 2016, 0.1 per cent less than forecast last month, the EIA said in its Short-Term Energy Outlook. Demand is expected to rise 270,000 bpd to 95.2 million barrels, up 0.3 per cent from September’s forecast.

Pointing up Oil executives at an industry conference in London, meanwhile, warned of a “dramatic” decline in U.S. output that could lead to a price spike if fuel demand escalates. Mark Papa, former head of U.S. shale producer EOG Resources, told the “Oil and Money” conference that U.S. production growth would tail off this month and start to decline early next year.

Russia’s energy minister said Russia and Saudi Arabia discussed the oil market in a meeting last week and would continue to consult each other.

OPEC Secretary-General Abdullah al-Badri said at a conference in London that OPEC and non-OPEC members should work together to reduce the global supply glut.

Iran’s crude sales were on track to hit seven-month lows as its main Asian customers bought less.

U.S. Oil Approaching $50 Boosts Stocks as Emerging Markets Surge

Ed Morse, head of commodity research at Citigroup, and Willem Buiter, chief economist at Citigroup, discuss why oil isn’t out of the woods with its recent price rise, the state of production in the Middle East and U.S. and the overall economic impact of lower oil prices. They speak on “Bloomberg Surveillance.”

EARNINGS WATCH
Hold tight for a bumpy US earnings season

(…) However, during the confusion in September, company managements were particularly reluctant to guide the market any way at all on their earnings. According to BofA Merrill Lynch, only 26 S&P 500 companies issued guidance last month, the lowest figure for any month since 2000. The monthly average over that period is 125. (…)

As for the US earnings season, we should buckle our seat belts. Analysts are flying blind, possibly because managements themselves have not known how to guide them. The dribble of early results makes plain some dramatic rebounds are possible, but also implies that any earnings misses will be punished severely. (…)

Either John Authers or BAML are missing something. Factset numbers as of October 2 show that 108 companies had issued guidance vs 109 at the same date last year and the year before. Thomson Reuters’ tally, which also includes “in-line guidance” is 133 pre-announcements so far vs 135 last year.

This latest piece by Authers follows his negatively slanted article of October 1:

And so far, the course of earnings gives better reason than almost anything else to suppose that the bear market is indeed under way.

To repeat my reply to Authers’ Oct. 1 article:

Some facts omitted by John Authers:

  • Analysts have lowered earnings estimates for the S&P 500 for Q3 2015 by a smaller margin than average. On a per-share basis, estimated earnings for the third quarter have fallen by 3.0% since June 30. This percentage decline is smaller than the trailing 5-year and 10-year averages at this same point in time in the quarter.
  • Fewer companies have lowered the bar for earnings for Q3 2015 as well. Of the 108 companies that have issued EPS guidance, 76 have issued negative EPS guidance and 32 have issued positive EPS guidance. The percentage of companies issuing negative EPS guidance is 70%, which is below the 5-year average of 72%.
  • More companies have issued positive guidance for Q3 than normal according to data from both Factset and Thomson Reuters. In fact, with the same number of companies having pre-announced, 33 (31%) have guided positively compared to 27 (25%) at the same time last year. This is the highest number of positive pre-announcements since at last 3 years.
  • If the Energy sector is excluded, the estimated earnings growth rate for the S&P 500 would jump to 2.9% from -4.5%.
  • As to the “dreadful earnings momentum” by sectors, Authers only refers to the semis. Here’s TR’s tally for 2016. Apart from commodity-related sectors, nothing too dreadful in this table.

image

Société Générale argues similarly (via Zerohedge)

US EPS growth has been very disappointing this year, with Q3 earnings likely to decline (yoy) for the second quarter in a row. Our Equity Quant team notes that profits growth has never been this weak outside of a recession. Consequently, risk aversion has increased, reinforced by fears of contagion across asset classes and notably the return of idiosyncratic risk in credit. The external headwinds of a strong USD, lower commodity prices and slower global demand should continue to weigh on sectors such as industrials, materials and energy. But, lower oil prices and a healthier job market (with the current soft patch likely to be transitory) are positive for US consumers, as reflected by strong spending data over the past months (+0.4% mom on average). As a result, sectors exposed to US consumption could still report solid EPS growth going forward. The eurozone recovery should also support earnings, allowing the Euro Stoxx to benefit from less demanding valuation levels.

Earnings Don’t Tell Full Economic Story The sharp drop in oil prices probably makes an earnings recession a flawed harbinger of economic growth

(…) The 0.6 percentage point drop in corporate profit margins in the past year is of a magnitude previously only seen prior to economic recessions. There was an exception, though: the one coinciding with the oil-price collapse in the mid-1980s.

The S&P 500 energy sector, for instance, is expected to adversely impact overall third-quarter earnings for the large-cap S&P index by 7.1 percentage points, per FactSet. Thus, if energy were excluded from the picture, profits would stand to expand 1.9% in the third quarter.

J.P. Morgan: Guide to the Markets, U.S. 4Q2015

Published quarterly, the JPM Guide to the Markets is a great source of charts on most things economy and finance related. Some of the most relevant with my comments:

  • The U.S. consumer, 70% of U.S. GDP and 17% of world GDP, is in great shape:

image

  • But the overall stats are skewed by the highest income earners. The average Joe still finds it difficult to get a mortgage in spite of record low mortgage rates. The hope is that employment growth will foster faster household formation among the prime house buying group (25-34 year age). This age group saw its employment rise 43k in September after +113k in August.

image

  • At the other age extreme, savers get no break:

image

  • Buy-low time for high yields? Yes, if no recession.

image

  • Europe is borrowing again.

image

  • DM valuations:

image

  • EM valuations: be careful, they are partly based on forward earnings…

image

  • …and EM earnings are still falling!

image

Money Fantasy sports: rule-playing games

(…) For most people it is a simple way to lose cash. The piles are won by a tiny fraction of the participants. And, the New York Times reported this week, some of those happen to be employees of FanDuel and DraftKings who have access to data on gaming patterns and who play on each other’s sites.

This humdrum fantasy always had an illicit thrill: it is dangerously close to online gambling, which is illegal in the US. The fantasy companies were banking on an exemption from that law. The “insider-betting” scandal makes that look precarious.

The US authorities may decide that fantasy is a harmless pastime that would be pointlessly difficult to police. Several UK-listed internet gambling companies bet on similar hopes a decade ago, running offshore gambling sites Americans could use. The reality was a crackdown — complete with executives arrested at airports — and the industry disintegrated.