The enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it’s the illusion of knowledge (Stephen Hawking)

It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so (Mark Twain)

Invest with smart knowledge and objective odds

THE DAILY EDGE: 21 OCTOBER 2020

Coronavirus Stimulus Talks Make Progress Despite Resistance White House and Democratic negotiators said they would press ahead with efforts to reach a coronavirus relief deal after making progress even as the prospect of a roughly $2 trillion package sparked opposition from Senate Republicans.

(…) White House chief of staff Mark Meadows said on CNBC that the day’s talks had been “productive enough to continue to have discussions tomorrow,” adding that Mrs. Pelosi and the administration were now trying to secure “some kind of agreement before the weekend.”

Any deal approaching $2 trillion would encounter deep resistance in the GOP-controlled Senate. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.) told Senate Republicans at their weekly lunch Tuesday that he had advised the White House not to divide the Senate GOP right before the election and that a $2 trillion relief bill would split the caucus, according to people familiar with the comments.

“That’s a high number to me,” Senate Appropriations Committee Chairman Richard Shelby (R., Ala.) said Tuesday of a deal upwards of $1.8 trillion. “I am not optimistic about us doing anything.” (…)

In the face of Senate GOP resistance, he [Trump] said he would be willing to pass the bill with largely Democratic votes. (…) “Just right now, procedurally, the mechanics of getting a deal done [before the election] would be challenging to say the least,” Mr. Thune said Tuesday. (…)

Mrs. Pelosi said that two policy issues remained the biggest sticking points: how much funding to include for state and local governments, and what kind of legal protections to provide businesses and other entities operating during the pandemic. (…)

Goldman Sachs yesterday:

The Senate voted down PPP funding today, and is likely to vote down the Senate Republican stimulus package tomorrow. The outcome of today’s vote was widely expected, as it appeared aimed mainly at putting senators on record. Tomorrow’s vote is also expected to fail, as Senate Democrats have already objected to the Republican proposal.

Negotiations are likely to continue, because neither side benefits from ending them. (…) Some of the biggest issues remain unresolved and a deal doesn’t seem particularly close. (…) even if a deal in principle is announced in coming days—this seems possible, but not likely—it looks very unlikely that it would pass before Election Day.

New York Faces $59 Billion Revenue Shortfall New York governments and authorities are projecting one of the deepest funding holes of any state through 2022 because of the continuing coronavirus crisis

Gov. Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat, said services will be cut and taxes will increase if Congress doesn’t pass another relief package—which Democrats say should include direct aid to states and cities hit by the pandemic. Mr. Cuomo said recently that he will postpone decisions in the hope that Democrats make gains on Election Day Nov. 3. (…)

Moody’s Investors Service is forecasting the fiscal shock to the state government will be $29 billion through the end of the 2022 fiscal year. That is 1.9% of gross state product, which is above the national average, said Moody’s economist Emily Mandel. (…)

Going into the pandemic, New York was the state with the seventh smallest rainy day fund, or cash it keeps on hand for an emergency, according to a study by the Pew Charitable Trusts. The combined $59 billion shortfall facing the state, transportation authorities and local governments represents more than half the state’s annual operating budget. (…)

“My position is, the state is not liable for this deficit. It was caused by the federal government’s negligence. So, I’m not taking action to close the deficit—the federal government has to make up for the deficit,” Mr. Cuomo said Oct. 7. (…)

The state has so-far postponed scheduled raises for public workers that were due in April. Some organizations and schools laid off employees as a result of the delays.

New York City officials said they are requiring managers and City Hall staff—including Mayor Bill de Blasio—to begin furloughs, but the Democratic mayor said last week that planned layoffs for public workers were on hold because he was able to defer payment of some back wages to teachers. (…)

Many Workers Gave Up Looking for Jobs Across the U.S. in September Declining unemployment rates in states masked signs of labor-market deterioration, data suggest

Workers gave up looking for jobs across the U.S. in September, with the size of the labor force shrinking in more than half of the 30 states in which unemployment rates fell last month, Labor Department data released Tuesday showed. (…)

In New York, some 300,000 workers came off the unemployment rolls in September, pushing the unemployment rate down 2.8 percentage points to 9.7%. But this wasn’t because of a hiring boom. Instead, the hard-hit state saw an even bigger number of workers stop searching for work, suggesting that workers who had been employed in August exited from the workforce, too. (…)

This busy chart gives all kinds of unemployment measures. U-6 (orange) is 12.8%, down from 22.8% in April but up from 7.0% in February. This is still missing some. e.g. the PEUC recipients. Estimates are that 25.3 million Americans were receiving some form of unemployment benefits at the end of September. That’s 15.8% of the labor force.

fredgraph - 2020-10-21T062002.632

Local government employment is down 939k (-6.4%) since February, a significant drop for what is normally a stabilising force during recessions. States and municipalities have had to close many services due to the pandemic. But the fiscal hit will come nonetheless and trigger more layoffs well after the crisis.

fredgraph - 2020-10-21T071938.073
U.S. Housing Starts Rebound in September

Housing starts rose 1.9% (11.1% y/y) in September to 1.415 million units (SAAR) from 1.388 million in August, revised from 1.416 million. The increase left starts 12.5% below their January peak of 1.617 million. The Action Economics Forecast Survey expected 1.450 million starts in September.

Starts of single-family homes rose 8.5% last month (22.3% y/y) to 1.108 million from an unrevised 1.021 million in August and 992,000 in July, revised from 981,000. The latest level was roughly two-thirds above the April low. Offsetting the increase was a 16.3% decline (-16.6% y/y) in multi-family starts to 307,000 units from 367,000 in August, revised from 395,000. It was the lowest level of multi-family start in five months and down 51.1% from the peak this past January.

Building permits rose 5.2% (8.1% y/y) to 1.553 million units from 1.476 million in August, revised from 1.470 million. It was the highest level of permits since March 2007. Permits to build single-family homes rose 7.8% (24.3% y/y) to 1.119 million, the fifth consecutive month of strong increase. Permits to build multi-family homes eased 0.9% (-19.2% y/y) to 434,000 after falling 13.4% in August.

By region, housing starts in the Northeast surged by two-thirds (26.1% y/y) to 145,000, the highest level since January. In the South, starts rose 6.2% (8.9% y/y) to 755,000 following August’s 15.3% decline. In the West, starts improved 1.4% (13.6% y/y) to 350,000, the highest level since February. To the downside were housing starts in the Midwest which fell 32.7% (+4.4% y/y) to 165,000. It was the lowest level in four months. (…)

 image image

Next two charts from Goldman Sachs:

image
image
Apartment Rents Are Plunging in the World’s Richest Cities. It’s Time For You to Negotiate Desire for space and stuck-at-home students weigh on formerly desirable areas — but for how long?

(…) In Westchester County — a region north of New York with more than 20,000 acres of parkland — purchase prices for single-family homes have surged 16% from a year ago.

By contrast, Manhattan apartments are the cheapest they’ve been since 2013. Listings have tripled from a year ago while the median rent has tumbled 11%, with even bigger declines for studios. (…)

The median monthly rent for a studio in San Francisco tumbled 31% in September from a year earlier to $2,285, compared with a 0.5% decline nationally, according to data released by Realtor.com.

[In Toronto], Rents have plunged, down 14.5% in the third quarter compared with the same period last year, according to data from research firm Urbanation Inc. Properties are also sitting on the market for longer — 26 days in August compared with 14 a year earlier. (…)

[In London], In the capital’s wealthiest areas, rents slumped 8.1% in the year through September, the steepest drop in more than a decade, according to broker Knight Frank. (…)

[Singapore] rental volumes of private units were down 8% from a year ago, according to data from real estate portal SRX Property. Rents are 17% lower than their peak in 2013. By contrast, home sales are at the highest level in more than two years. (…)

Canadian home prices rise in September as housing market firms, according to Teranet data

The Teranet-National Bank Composite House Price Index, which tracks data collected from public land registries to measure changes for repeat sales of single-family homes, showed prices rose 1.1 per cent in September from August.

In addition to the 11 major markets included in the index, Teranet also tracks 20 other cities across the country. All 31 posted gains for the month, the first across-the-board monthly gain since tracking of the current bundle began in 2009.

Prices were up 2.3 per cent in the capital region of Ottawa-Gatineau and 2.2 per cent in Quebec City, with Montreal and Hamilton both up 1.9 per cent in September from August.

On a year-over-year basis, the index was up 6.7 per cent in September, rising at a faster pace than the previous month. (…)

Pfizer Sets Up Its ‘Biggest Ever’ Vaccination Distribution Campaign The drugmaker is urgently laying the groundwork so it can move quickly if its vaccine gets the go-ahead from the Food and Drug Administration and other regulators around the world.

(…) The U.S. pharmaceutical giant says it wants to deliver up to 100 million doses this year and another 1.3 billion in 2021. (…) Pfizer says it may know whether its vaccine works by the end of October and that it could be ready to apply for emergency-use authorization of its Covid-19 vaccine by late November. (…)

Cargo airlines are scrambling to arrange scores of extra flights to move the vaccines. They could hit distribution channels at the height of the peak season for shipping goods ahead of the year-end holidays, squeezing expedited shipping capacity. (…)

Will a vaccine stop Covid? Even if it’s effective, the logistics of delivering it are monumental
Roche CEO Warns Against High Hopes for Speedy Covid Vaccines

It is “completely unrealistic” to expect a Covid-19 vaccine to be widely available by the end of this year, and most people probably won’t have access to a shot until the second half of 2021, Schwan said in an interview with Bloomberg TV anchor Francine Lacqua. Companies need time to test the candidates in enough people to be sure they’re safe and then scale up production, he said. Though Roche isn’t working on a coronavirus vaccine, it’s partnering with Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc. on a potential treatment. (…)

Novartis CEO Vas Narasimhan cited a similar late-2021 timeline in an interview last month. Pfizer Inc., one of the leaders in the vaccine race, said last week it wouldn’t be able to apply for an emergency authorization for use in the U.S. before late November of this year — and that it will need to continue monitoring safety for two years. And because not everyone will choose to get the shot, Covid-19 will probably be endemic even if a vaccine is available, said David Ricks, CEO of Eli Lilly & Co.

THE SHORT AND THE LONG OF IT

One of the inputs causing our sentiment models to become extremely positive in March, and then stay elevated into May, was the behavior of speculators in the major equity index futures contracts. They shorted heavily and remained short through much of this rally.

Commercial hedgers take the opposite sides of large and small speculators, so hedgers were curiously net long since March. Over the past decade, in particular, a large net long position by this “smart money” group has invariably been an excellent buy signal.

That changed in a drastic way in the past week. Thanks to a dramatic change in positioning in the Nasdaq 100, hedgers’ positions cycled from a large net long position to a large net short one. Over the past couple of years, when their net short neared $40 billion, stocks struggled.

Historically, hedgers have established much larger shorts against stocks than they have now, so the absolute level of their exposure isn’t too troubling. But when hedgers have been net long for at least 6 weeks and then flipped to a net short position, stocks have struggled over the short- to medium-term. (SentimenTrader)

Smart money commercial hedger in equities

THE DAILY EDGE: 5 JUNE 2020

NOTE: It seems that Mailchimp failed to send yesterday’s Daily Edge to subscribers. You will find it right below today’s.

  • Russia, Mexico, Brazil all see alarming jump in cases, deaths
  • Hong Kong sees another alarming cluster
  • Florida reports most new cases since April for 2nd straight day. Payback for recent beach parties?
Instagram founders launch COVID-19 spread tracker Rt.live 

Rt.live is an up-to-date tracker of how fast COVID-19 is spreading in each state. “Rt” measures the average number of people who become infected by an infectious person. The higher above the number 1, the faster COVID-19 races through a population, while a number below one shows the virus receding. For example, Rt.live displays that Georgia has the highest, most dangerous Rt score of 1.5 while New York is down to 0.54 thanks to aggressive shelter-in-place orders. (…)

Rt.live shows that as of yesterday, Texas and California are at or just under 1 and Vermont has the best score at 0.33.

Rice: Bank of America says the staple food for half of the world’s population has jumped 70% since January, on a COVID-19 labor supply chain hit and stockpiling. (Axios)

The Goldman Sachs Analyst Index (GSAI) rebounded by 5.5pt to 29.2 in May. The composition of the rebound was mixed, as the sales and orders components increased but the employment component pulled back. The levels of all three components continued to indicate widespread contraction. The inventories, output prices, material prices, and wages components rose, while the exports component declined.

1. GSAI Rebounded in May, but Still Severely Depressed. Data available on request.
Hotels: Occupancy Rate Declined 43.2% Year-over-year, Seventh Consecutive Week of Higher Demand
The next big problem for the economy: Businesses can’t pay their rent Nearly half of commercial retail rents were not paid in April and May

The problem for the broader U.S. economy is that when businesses like Ross Stores and T.J. Maxx stop paying rent, it sets off an alarming chain reaction. Landlords are now at risk of bankruptcy, too. Commercial real estate prices are falling. Jobs at property management companies and landscapers face cuts. Banks and private investors are unwilling to lend to most commercial real estate projects anymore, and cash-strapped city and local governments are realizing the property taxes they usually rely on from business properties are unlikely to be paid this summer and fall. (…)

Lawmakers are trying to figure out how to prevent businesses — as well as their landlords — from going out of business, but government leaders are struggling to figure out how to help.

Some landlords are asking local governments to delay property tax collections, but many municipalities are already financially strained as tax proceeds plunge and costs skyrocket during the pandemic. (…)

This Time, Europe Hasn’t Thrown Away Its Shot Common borrowing is a historic step that would address a critical flaw in the single currency zone’s architecture.

(…) Germany, whose determination to maintain fiscal austerity is at the center of the euro zone’s problems, is now moving ahead with a 130 billion euro stimulus program, which chancellor Angela Merkel described as “courageous and decisive.” These measures give Europe a more coherent response to the pandemic than many thought possible. (…)

Another strong case in favor comes from Anatole Kaletsky of Gavekal Economics. First, he points out, the bonds will be issued by the EU in its own name, avoiding any confusion of joint guarantees. Second, and perhaps most important, this implies tax-raising power for the EU, beyond its current income from customs duties and a small share of value added taxes. Kaletsky suggests that this will need to be raised from “economic activities which transcend national boundaries” — so maybe a tax on carbon, financial transactions or digital activities. Finally, he points out, the proposal allows the EU to leverage itself. Interest rates are at rock bottom, so this could soon become a mechanism for dealing with far more than coronavirus relief. (…)

CMHC to tighten lending standards for home buyers Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. is toughening up its rules to make it harder to get mortgage insurance, a move that would reduce demand from riskier borrowers and keep prices in check at a time of economic uncertainty.

Trump’s Re-Election Hopes Grow Shakier With Biden Gains A shifting battlefield map is imperiling Donald Trump’s re-election.

Democrat Joe Biden has pulled further ahead in the industrial Midwestern states that Trump won in 2016, as Trump’s handling of the coronavirus and the resulting job losses prompted a precipitous slide in his support.

Trump summoned top political advisers to the White House Thursday for a meeting to reverse the decline. (…)

Biden’s average lead in national polls has inched up 2 points over the last week, and he is now ahead of Trump by almost 8 points, his largest lead since December.

But it’s the Electoral College that chooses presidents, and Biden’s standing in battleground states has begun to repair the so-called “blue wall” of loyally Democratic states that Trump toppled in 2016. The former vice president now has consistent leads of 4 points in Pennsylvania, 4.2 points in Michigan and 3.4 points in Wisconsin.

(…) Biden’s hill to climb remains steep, with little room for error. If the rest of the map stays the same as 2016, Biden would need all three states to reach the 270 electoral votes necessary to claim the White House.

But the 2020 map so far looks significantly different in ways that could help Biden. He holds a substantial lead in Arizona, for example, a state that Trump won by more than 5 points in 2016. The former vice president believes he could be competitive or even win in Florida, North Carolina, Ohio and even Texas– all states that Trump comfortably won on his way to the White House. (…)

“If the election were held today, Donald Trump would lose,” said Republican strategist Terry Sullivan. “But the election isn’t today, it’s in five months. If we’ve learned anything over the last three-and-a-half years, it’s that five months out is a lifetime.” (…)

The president’s average approval rating in the RealClearPolitics average fell to 42.8% Thursday, its lowest point since November (…)

(…) “There’s absolutely zero chance” of reaching the purchase commitment announced in January when the deal was reached, said Joe Glauber, the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s former chief economist. “They’re just so far behind.” (…)

The U.S. Agriculture Department last week lowered its forecast for exports of farm goods to China by $1 billion, based on reduced demand. (…)

But the USDA forecast amounts to $8 billion in sales to China for the first nine months of this year, meaning another $28.5 billion would be required in the last quarter to fulfill Trump’s promise of $36.5 billion for the year. The last-quarter total would be more than double the largest exports on record for that time period, $12.4 billion in 2013.

China bought $4.65 billion in U.S. farm-related products in the first four months of the year, only slightly higher than $4.3 billion in the same period last year, which came in the middle of a trade war.

A Peterson Institute analysis concluded that U.S exports to China of agricultural products are running at only 38% of the pace set in the trade deal. (…)

Trump’s answer has been another bailout for farmers. After the president authorized back-to-back trade bailouts totaling $28 billion over two years, the administration in April announced a $19 billion rescue for farmers, using money Congress appropriated in its last coronavirus relief package. More aid is widely anticipated in the next virus spending bill Congress considers. (…)

Lawmakers in Eight Countries Form New Alliance to Counter China

A group of senior lawmakers from eight democracies including the U.S. have launched a new cross-parliamentary alliance to help counter what they say is the threat China’s growing influence poses to global trade, security and human rights.

The Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China, which launched Friday, comes as the U.S. struggles to muster a cohesive alliance to take on China’s growing economic and diplomatic clout and as it leads foreign governments in condemning Beijing’s move to impose national security legislation on Hong Kong that threatens the city’s autonomy. (…)

The alliance said China’s economic rise is putting the global, rules-based order under pressure and that countries that have tried to stand up to Beijing have mostly done so alone — and “often at great cost.” The list of participating nations includes the U.S., Germany, U.K., Japan, Australia, Canada, Sweden, Norway, as well as members of the European parliament. (…)

“The time has come for democratic countries to unite in a common defense of our shared values,” Smith, the U.K. lawmaker, said on Twitter.

China Says It Will Take ‘Necessary Measures’ on U.S. Blacklist The Chinese government said it will take “necessary measures” to safeguard the interests of domestic companies, after fresh U.S. restrictions on a blacklist of 33 companies took effect Friday.
SENTIMENT WATCH
The Bulls Have Taken Back the Stock Market The S&P 500 is up nearly 40% in just the past 50 trading days, the largest such rally since 1957

(…) It has been a long time since anyone has called Boeing a winner, but the company’s stock staged a big rebound this week. Shares were up about 26% through Thursday, far and away the biggest move among the 30 Dow components. (…)

Boeing sits in the middle of many of the swirling issues in the markets. Its primary customers are airlines, which are under duress. They need business people and tourists to resume traveling. And for that to happen, the economy needs to recover, and progress needs to be made toward a coronavirus vaccine.

If those things don’t happen, it is hard to see how Boeing grows. (…)

Streetwise: Why Mr. Market Ignores a World in Turmoil

(…) Today’s question for the audience is: Why is the market rising even as U.S. cities burn, Hong Kong becomes a flashpoint in China relations with the West and the prospect of a second round of coronavirus infections remains real? (…)

The bullish story is that none of these problems matter nearly as much for stock prices as the good news for investors. Businesses are reopening while the Fed is providing unprecedented support and governments are subsidizing the economy to the tune of 11% of GDP in developed countries, Fitch Ratings calculates. (…)

The unrest and Donald Trump’s response have increased the chance of Joe Biden winning the presidency in November according to betting odds. But it is too early to be sure whether a message of “law and order” will help or hinder Mr. Trump in the polls. Aside from specific sectors, it’s also hard to know if the market as a whole would do worse from a president (Trump) threatening more tariffs, or a president (Biden) threatening more taxes. Higher taxes hurt more, but since they depend on Congress, investors might prefer to bet on gridlock. (…)

Meanwhile, there has been mixed news on the risks of a second round of infections as lockdowns end. Sporadic coronavirus outbreaks continue in South Korea despite a well-run test-and-trace system, while Israel has closed some schools again after infections spread; in many other countries the reopening has gone smoothly. Big rallies and widespread arrests raise the risk of a surge of infections in the U.S. both among protesters and police, but it will be weeks before we know. (…)

The market is probably ignoring incremental bad news because momentum has control. All those who missed the rally are buying in now that lockdown is easing, pushing up prices. The S&P 500 had its best-ever 50-day gain from the March lows to Wednesday. The prospect of a new high helps too: the Nasdaq-100 index dominated by big technology stocks briefly broke to a new high on Wednesday, while the S&P 500 is down only 3% this year (and less than 8% below its high).

(…) Easy money makes up for a lot of lost earnings. But market momentum always breaks eventually.

A big difference between this market and that of 2009 is that this one is trading on hope(s) whereas the 2009 upturn was fighting widespread despair and disbelief. Both trends were fueled by central bank easing and momentum. In 2009, “normalized” earnings were anathema. In 2020, the “V” recovery is expected to take care of everything. Like if nothing really happened…

Moody’s illustrates this Victory mentality with this next chart:

Core profits apply to all U.S. corporation s, as opposed to just the member companies of the S&P 500.Core profits exclude extraordinary gains and losses and changes in inventory valuations, while also employing economic depreciation instead of accounting depreciation.

Ordinarily, deep year-over-year declines by core after-tax profits are accompanied by year-to-year declines for the market value of U.S. common stock. For example, when calendar-year 2008’s core aftertax profits sank by 9.8% annually, year-end 2008’s market value of U.S. common stock closed 38.7%
under its year-end 2007 mark.

image

Surprised smile Next Twelve Months P/E: Mega-Cap Growth Stocks vs. S&P 500 ex Mega-Cap Growth

Next Twelve Months P/E: Mega-Cap Growth Stocks vs. S&P 500 ex Mega-Cap Growth

The Institutional Investor Fear Index: No Business-as-Usual Anytime Soon

Investors pump record $22.5bn into US bond funds Cash infusion over past week is the highest since 2007, when EPFR started tracking