The enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it’s the illusion of knowledge (Stephen Hawking)

It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so (Mark Twain)

Invest with smart knowledge and objective odds

NEW$ & VIEW$ (9 DECEMBER 2015): China; Canada; Oil

NFIB: Small Business Index Declined in November

“During this holiday season, small business owners are finding little to be hopeful or optimistic about including the economy in the New Year. This month’s Index continues to signal a lackluster economy and shows that the small business sector has no expansion energy whatsoever.” — Bill Dunkelberg, NFIB Chief Economist

NFIB Optimism Index

Fifty-five percent reported hiring or trying to hire (unchanged), but 47 percent reported few or no qualified applicants for the positions they were trying to fill. Sixteen percent reported using temporary workers, up 2 points. Twenty-seven percent of all owners reported job openings they could not fill in the current period, unchanged over the past 2 months. This is a solid reading historically and suggests no significant change in the unemployment rate.

Hiring, Firing and Quitting Have Finally Gotten Close to Where Janet Yellen Wants Them Since 2013, three indicators have improved the way now-Chairwoman Janet Yellen had hoped.

(…) In March of 2013, about 2.1 million workers quit their jobs, a rate of about 1.5%. Those numbers have improved slowly enough that the improvement is hard to notice from one month to the next (in this month’s report, all the key measures were “little changed”). But over the course of the past two and a half years, the improvement has been considerable. In October, 2.8 million people quit their jobs, a rate of 1.9%—roughly the same as in December 2007, the month the economy began to decline into recession. Ms. Yellen had said in her speech “a pickup in the quit rate, which also remains at a low level, would signal that workers perceive that their chances to be rehired are good–in other words, that labor demand has strengthened.” Put another way, just under half of the people who left a job in March 2013 did so voluntarily. The majority of job separations were still involuntary layoffs or departures due to retirement, death or disability. Among people who left a job in October, by contrast, 57% did so voluntarily. (…)

MEMO TO YELLEN

It’s hard to be bullish about the global economy these days. Besides China’s tricky rebalancing, which continues to have repercussions across the globe, there’s the growing threat posed by the surging US dollar. The trade-weighted greenback’s over 12% appreciation this year (2015 average versus 2014 average) is the biggest annual appreciation in over thirty years, and that raises the odds of corporate defaults worldwide. According to the latest Quarterly Review from the Bank for International Settlements, the stock of dollar-denominated debt held by non-financial entities outside the US grew to $9.8 trillion in the second quarter of 2015. As today’s Hot Chart shows, that’s a record not just in absolute terms but also as a percentage of GDP. The latter, at almost 18% of World GDP excluding the US, suggests global exposure to a strengthening USD is now twice as large as it was 20 years ago. (NBF)

image

From Deutsche Bank:

EM’s increased issuance of the previous years, and thus building debts have been under increasing scrutiny. The charts below show that this leveraging has been concentrated in corporates. In fact, as we discuss in “EM: Cornered” in this publication, rising sovereign debt levels is hardly a systemic issue. While EM government debt levels have only moderately increased over the past few years, nonfinancial EM corporate debt has seen a dramatic rise after the GFC of 2008. Specifically, it rose from a level of around 60% of GDP in 2008 to the current level of close to 90% of GDP (see graph below).

We have followed the case of corporates closely and – although it does not yet seem to pose serious systemic risks either – shrinking liquidity buffers and reduced
EBTDAs could lead to more funding stress if 2016 ends with still gloomy prospects for EM economies and commodities. (…)

 image image

Interest coverage (EBITDA to interest expense) has been declining among EM corporates due to declining EBITDA (on lower growth and weaker commodity prices). However, interest coverage remains above 2x for most of the universe of EM corporates – in other words, EM corporates’ solvency is unlikely to be challenged as an asset class in 2016, in our view. (…)

Further weakness in commodity prices and EMFX, coupled with a 38% spike in EM corporate bond maturities, could lead to increased stress in 2017
The liquidity picture for EM corporates in 2017 looks less appealing, due to a 38% yoy increase in USD bond maturities (to USD122bn) and lingering uncertainty on commodity prices (an important component of the corporate sectors’ cash flow) and FX (a headwind for domestic-oriented players). A further depletion in cash buffers and reduced appetite for certain portions of the EM corporate universe may lead to increased refinancing stress in 2017 – especially if inflationary pressures build and domestic liquidity conditions also have to be tightened. (…)

Within Asia, China is the biggest contributor with corporate debt at over 110% of GDP. While we are concerned about China’s growth slowdown and leveraged corporate balance sheets, we note that onshore liquidity remains strong and that is unlikely to change in 2016 with our economists forecasting two rate cuts and four RRR cuts. FX is also an important point to monitor, given the lack of USD revenue among a good chunk of Chinese corporates.

CHINA
CEBM Research November survey:

The steel market continued to deteriorate in November, with prices falling sharply by an average of about 200 RMB per ton. Weather factors including low temperatures, rain, and snow have curtailed demand for construction materials and placed downward pressure on steel prices. With the market entering the traditional low season, survey respondents were generally pessimistic.

Real estate survey respondents reported a healthy level of sales activity during November. Looking at new starts activity, a majority of respondents expect the low level of starts activity observed in previous months to persist in December due to inventory overhang.

Autos: survey respondents reported a second consecutive month of better-than-expected sales driven by the September purchase tax cut on small autos, the upcoming expirations of new energy vehicle subsidies, and seasonal factors. Survey feedback reveals that inventory levels at dealers selling small-engine domestic vehicles has fallen considerably, with some dealers reporting stock shortages. Among this month’s survey respondents, November sales grew by a range of 10% to 15% on an annual basis. A majority of respondents have further upgraded their 4Q15 sales forecasts from last month and have also upgraded their full year 2016 forecasts.

Container freight: the yearlong 2015 slump for container freight exporters continues with few signs of improvement in external demand.

Bank loans: based on survey feedback, the scale of loan issuance in November changed very little from the previous month.

China’s Inflation Stabilizes as Stimulus Helps Support Demand

The consumer-price index rose 1.5 percent in November from a year earlier, the National Bureau of Statistics said Wednesday, compared to the 1.4 percent median estimate in a Bloomberg survey and 1.3 percent in October. The producer-price index fell 5.9 percent, compared to a projected 6 percent drop, extending declines to a record 45 months. (…)

Inflation firmed with help from a 2.1 increase for services, while slower declines in imports signal demand is stabilizing after six central bank interest rate cuts since November last year and expanded government spending.

The increase for services was offset by a 1.2 percent gain for consumer goods. Food prices climbed 2.3 percent while non-food items rose 1.1 percent, continuing their rebound from January’s 0.6 percent gain that was the slowest in five years.

 
China Sets Yuan at Four-Year Low in ‘Stress Test’ Facing currency outflows and a weakening economy, Beijing guided the yuan to its weakest level against the dollar in more than four years.

The central bank is testing how far it can let market forces go in determining the yuan’s value without setting off a sharp selloff and incurring wrath from trading partners, according to people familiar with the matter. (…)

The yuan has lost as much as 3.4% of its value since Aug. 10, the eve of the 2% devaluation. (…)

Mr. Zhang and other analysts now think the yuan is overvalued relative to its purchasing power, forcing Chinese companies to cut prices and lower wages to stay competitive, which could raise the specter of deflation.

“At the same time, the central bank should attach high importance to the risks associated with depreciation, such as Chinese companies’ abilities to repay dollar-denominated debts and its potential impact on currencies of China’s trading partners in Southeast Asia,” he said. (…)

CANADA HOUSING

Much has been written on the speculative nature of the Vancouver and Toronto residential markets and the threat it poses to the Canadian economic outlook. For some pundits, the current divergence in home price inflation between these two major cities and the rest of the country cannot be warranted by fundamentals, i.e. how could housing demand continue to strive in Toronto and Vancouver against a backdrop of uninspiring job creation at the national level if not for speculative forces?

But before putting the blame on speculators, consider latest labour market trends at the municipal level. As today’s Hot Chart shows, job creation has actually been quite strong in Toronto and Vancouver in recent quarters when compared to the national average. Large inflows of permanent immigrants (about 240,000 in the past year) coupled with the misfortune of commodity-producing regions have redirected inter and intra-provincial population migration flows towards Toronto and Vancouver. The good news is that these productive resources have for the most part been absorbed by the job market. So long as this situation endures, home prices in those two cities are unlikely to weaken significantly. (NBF)

image

Poloz Says Canada Quite Far From Extraordinary Stimulus

Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz said the nation’s economy remains “quite far” from needing unconventional policies such as quantitative easing to spur growth, with a weaker Canadian dollar and recent rate cuts accelerating the recovery.

“We believe there’s a reasonable probability that two years from now we’ll be back at 2 percent inflation, the economy operating at full capacity,” Poloz said in the interview. “So if something were to happen that pushed us significantly outside that zone, that’s when we’d need to look at, well, what are our options,”

Canadian financial markets were rattled this week by fresh signs of weakness in China and growing concerns a global oil glut will keep prices low. Still, Canada remains on track for faster growth in the next two years, and the economy will return to full capacity by mid-2017, Poloz said in a speech and press conference in Toronto. (…)

Poloz also refused to characterize Canada’s economic contraction in the first half of this year as a recession, arguing the economy was growing outside of energy. Canada’s economy expanded again in the third quarter.

“We still wouldn’t call it a recession, it’s a mild contraction, because it was really a very pinpointed kind of thing, and we could see the other sources of growth continuing to gather momentum,” he said. (…)

OIL
Rifts test Opec’s co-operative worth

(…) Although Mr Zanganeh said he hopes for agreement at the next meeting, even he, in private, is aware of the reality.

“The minister often uses a Persian proverb saying ‘You can wake a person who is sleeping, but not a person who is pretending to’,” said the former Opec official of Iran’s inability to convince Saudi Arabia of its position.

When Oil Turns 40, the Aches Turn Into Real Pain Crude oil prices below $40 mean more pain, but also a stronger eventual rebound for those who can survive that long

(…) Compared with the summer of 2014 when prices last peaked, forecasts of earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization for the world’s five largest, private integrated oil and gas companies have dropped by eye-popping $232 billion in 2015 and 2016 combined—or about 42%—according to FactSet. The five largest exploration and production companies have seen that proxy of cash flow drop by $83 billion, or close to 60%.

And those assumptions still are based on forecasts that Brent prices will bounce back to a less painful average of $60 a barrel or so in 2016. They might, but a producer wishing to lock in a price for a barrel a year from now will receive barely $48 in the futures market. Complicating matters, some large companies remain committed to stable or, in the case of Exxon Mobil and Chevron, rising dividends. (…)

Bloomberg:

(…) U.S. shale producers have so far escaped much of the fallout from lower oil prices thanks to the willingness of banks to keep the credit spigots open and the companies’ use of price hedges that have helped to cushion the blow. But those hedges are widely expected to end next year and seem unlikely to be replaced on such favorable terms. Meanwhile, the most recent discussions between oil producers and their lenders saw the companies’ average borrowing base slip 5 percent, according to a Citigroup analysis titled “Stayin’ Alive.” Stripping out the 42 percent of oil companies that saw their borrowing bases stay the same and the lucky few who saw it increase, the average drop was a staggering 19 percent and is only expected to decline further next year. U.S. shale producers may be stayin’ alive for now, but it seems increasingly likely that next year will not be all right, or ok.

Energy Sector’s Junk-Bond Pain Spreads Investors prepare for a wave of defaults next year

(…) Bonds from electric utilities including Dynegy Inc., AES Corp. and NRG Energy Inc.have declined in recent days, reflecting concerns that falling natural-gas prices will drag down electricity prices as well. A Dynegy bond is down 10.9​ cents on the dollar over the past week to 85.6 cents, an AES Corp. bond is down 4.8 cents to 85.3 cents and a bond from NRG Energy is down 8.9 cents to 84 cents, according to trading data fromMarketAxess Holdings Inc.

“Sentiment is awful,” said Henry Peabody, who helps oversee the $1 billion Eaton Vance Bond Fund. “We’re flirting with credit-crisis energy prices, and we’re probably flirting with credit-crisis bond prices to some degree in these sectors.” (…)

Analysts React to Oil’s Fall: Current Prices ‘Fundamentally Unsustainable’

Here’s a roundup of what analysts are saying about the oil patch right now.

Citi: Saudi’s current oil policy, that has in-part accelerated oil’s collapse, has driven prices far lower and for far longer than the Kingdom expected. Commitment to this strategy hasn’t wavered and looking ahead to 2016, the key question is will the Saudis be faced with similar disappointments come end-2016 or will they be exiting the year in the belief that they’ve “won.”

In any case, a victory for the Saudis will surely be a Pyrrhic one given the crippling effect on their fiscal balances in addition to the potentially huge effects that the sharply lower oil price is having on deflating production costs. The negative feed-back loop that lower oil prices are having is another adverse unforeseen consequence. The lack of 2016 producer hedging, and a WTI futures curve entirely sub-$60/bbl (out to 2024), leaves the Saudis with a clear incentive to keep prices low near-term. (…)

Julius Baer: Today’s oil price levels seem fundamentally unsustainable and can only be justified with a severe slowdown in world oil demand or significant productivity gains i.e. cost improvements of U.S. shale. Either seems unlikely. However, as the oil market transitions into a new normal out of the past decade’s super cycle, the rebalancing of supply and demand usually takes longer than expected. Instead, the steepness of the futures curve suggests that sentiment and technical selling momentum have been the key drivers of oil’s downward move as of late. The market is in surplus but not at risk of hitting capacity constraints due to recent storage expansions. (…)

TAC Energy:  WTI…has traded below the $37 mark three times before in the past decade – all during the Great Recession of 2008/2009 – but was never able to settle a month below the $40 mark.

While crude oil futures have reached multi-year lows, both Bakken and WCS cash prices remain above their August lows.  This could spell bad news for U.S. refiners as their regional crude advantage seems to be diminishing as more of the globe sinks under the weight of excess supply.

Commerzbank: A high oversupply is weighing on prices on many energy markets. This should change next year, above all on the oil market, because non-OPEC supply is falling more sharply than at any time in over twenty years. As the oversupply should have been erased by year-end, the oil price is likely to recover significantly in the second half of the year.(…)

NEW$ & VIEW$ (8 DECEMBER 2015)

U.S. Consumer Credit Growth Slows Americans added to their debt at a slower pace in October, suggesting cautious spending on the part of consumers at the start of the holiday season.

Outstanding consumer credit, a reflection of all debt besides mortgages, rose $15.98 billion or at a 5.5% annual rate in October, the Federal Reserve said Monday. That’s a tapering from September, when it rose at a revised annual rate of 9.9%, but a slight increase from August, when it grew at a 5.1% pace.

Revolving credit, mostly credit cards, rose at an annual 0.2% rate, sharply lower than in September, when it increased at an annual rate of 8.7%. October’s rate was the smallest gain since February.

Non-revolving credit, made up largely of auto or student loans, rose at a 7.4% annual rate, a slower pace than the revised 10.3% rate in September.

Haver Analytics says that during the last ten years, there has been a 47% correlation between the y/y growth in consumer credit and y/y growth in personal consumption expenditures.

large image
 

Pointing up Bespoke Investment charts consumer credit growth in real terms:

fed
In November, U.S. Consumer Spending Level at $92

We will get the November retail sales from the Commerce Department on Friday. In the meantime:

Americans’ daily self-reports of spending averaged $92 in November. This is the same as the October average, and remains slightly higher than the other monthly averages to date in 2015.

Trend: Monthly Averages of Reported Amount Americans Spent "Yesterday"

Each day, Gallup asks Americans how much they spent “yesterday” in restaurants, gas stations, stores or online — not counting home, vehicle or other major purchases, or normal monthly bills — to provide an indication of Americans’ discretionary spending. The November 2015 average of $92 is based on interviews with more than 14,000 U.S. adults.

While the November 2015 spending average is slightly below the $95 found in November 2014, it is similar to the $91 in November 2013. Other November averages since 2008 have been lower, between $66 and $87.

Gallup found that average daily spending increased significantly this year during the last few days of November and on Black Friday specifically. This spending increase could be a good sign as the U.S. enters the December holiday shopping period. Historically, spending increases by about $5 between November and December, although smaller increases were seen in 2008 and 2014.

Trend: Comparison of Average Reported U.S. Consumer Spending, October-December

In 2010, 2013 and 2014, spending increased from October to November, but it was stable or even decreased slightly in all other years. Last year, there was a large increase, $6, from October to November, but then a smaller one, $3, from November to December. Other than 2015, 2012 was the most recent year when spending was level between October and November. That same year saw a $10 jump between November and December, the largest jump Gallup has found between these two months.

Strong, consistent spending in November is a good sign for December spending. Consumer spending generally sees a boost as the year draws to a close, as a result of holiday shopping. And strong December spending is important to the health of the U.S. economy, because spending accounts for about two-thirds of the U.S. gross domestic product.

Remember that November 2015 was exceptionally warm across the USA.

Whirlpool Corp.:

Stronger consumer spending, especially on long-lasting durable goods, has bolstered growth at the Michigan-based appliance maker, which is hiring “in just about every U.S. location,” said James Keppler, the company’s vice president for integrated supply chain and quality for North America.

Chinese imports fall as economy struggles Renminbi heads for weakest close in 4 years

Imports fell 8.7 per cent in US dollar terms in November compared with a year earlier, trimming losses after a 12.6 per cent drop in October, customs data showed on Tuesday. Exports for November fell 6.8 per cent year-on-year, steeper than the 5 per cent fall in October. (…)

“Commodity prices extended their downward slide in November, but import volumes rebounded. The rise in crude oil imports probably reflects the increase in strategic reserves, while iron ore stockpiles at ports have continued to increase, suggesting that final demand hasn’t improved much,” economists at China International Capital Corp led by Liu Liu wrote on Tuesday.

Japan Avoids Second Recession of Abenomics Era Stronger-than-expected capital spending helped the Japanese economy grow in the third quarter, revised figures show.

Japan’s gross domestic product, the broadest measure of a nation’s economic activity, grew 1.0% in the third quarter from the prior three-month period on a seasonally adjusted annualized basis, the Cabinet Office said Tuesday. Previously it had estimated that the economy shrank 0.8% on that basis in the third quarter.

The upward revision allows the government of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to say the economy is on a recovery track after a revised decline of 0.5% in the second quarter. (…)

A main reason for the revision was business investment, which was initially estimated to have shrunk 5% in the quarter on an annualized basis. The revision showed it increased 2.3%. (…)

OIL

(…) The El Niño weather phenomenon has limited demand for natural gas and other heating fuels in the U.S. this year. Forecasts released Monday show above-average temperatures persisting for the next two weeks, at a time of year when demand for indoor heating is typically robust.

Temperatures in cities in the Midwest and East Coast could range between 15 and 25 degrees warmer than usual for the next 10 days, says Matt Rogers, meteorologist and president at Commodity Weather Group LLC.

Some traders say it is risky to bet on further declines for oil prices that are already down 29% on the year and well below $40—a level under which analysts say many producers can’t make money and will have to cut back. (…)

(…) The mean adjusted 2016 EPS estimate for Exxon Mobil Corp. has been cut by more than 9 cents a share and for Royal Dutch Shell Plc by 8.4 cents over the past month, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. EPS projections for Total SA, Europe’s second-biggest oil company, and Repsol SA are lower for 2016 than those for this year.

Those estimates assume a much higher price than the $41.19 a barrel that Brent traded at as of 9:57 a.m. in London on Tuesday. Oswald Clint, a London-based analyst with Sanford C. Bernstein has based his EPS estimates for oil majors at a Brent price of $60 a barrel, he said by phone Dec. 7. Alexandre Andlauer, a Paris-based oil sector analyst with AlphaValue SAS, has assumed a price of $63. (…)

There are several striking parallels between the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries’ current situation and the period from 1997 to 1999, when the group lost control of the market and oil slipped to less than $10 a barrel. While investors may wonder whether markets will follow a similar trajectory this time, it’s important to remember that OPEC emerged from the crisis to see oil prices surge all the way to almost $150 a barrel. If the parallels hold, markets could be in for a wild ride.

Nearly two decades ago, Venezuela had a growth spurt that lifted its output from 2.2 million barrels a day in 1992 to 3.5 million barrels a day six years later. Saudi Arabia responded by increasing its own production, flooding the market. This time around, Saudi Arabia has embarked on a production spree — pumping a record of 10.6 million barrels a day earlier this year — while Iran plans to boost daily output by as much as 1 million barrels next year after sanctions are lifted.

As OPEC lifted production in 1997, Asia headed into economic meltdown. The devaluation in July that year of the baht, the currency of Thailand, triggered a financial crisis that pushed Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand into recession. The group’s GDP contracted 8.3 percent in 1998, compared to growth of 7.5 percent on average the previous decade, according to data from the International Monetary Fund. While Asia isn’t collapsing this time around, China is experiencing the slowest expansion in 25 years.

The oil slump of 1997 to 1999 was compounded by El Nino, which curbed demand for heating fuel by warming the ocean surface in the equatorial Pacific and making fall and winter in the Northern hemisphere milder than normal. Fast forward to 2015 and El Nino is already comparable to the record events of those years, according to the Bureau of Meteorology of Australia. Heating oil stockpiles in the U.S. and northern Europe are high, potentially affecting overall crude demand.

Just as they were nearly two decades ago, Saudi Arabia’s al-Naimi and Iranian Oil Minister Bijan Namdar Zanganeh stand in opposition across the conference table in Vienna. Both have a long history of working together to resolve oil gluts, but the differences loom larger this time as their nations’ conflicting positions on Syria, Yemen and Iraq get in the way of the business of oil. (…)

(Bespoke Investment)

Anglo American to Slash Assets, Cut 85,000 Jobs, Suspend Dividend Anglo American announced a radical restructuring of its business that includes more asset sales and cutting 63% of its workforce in a bid to weather the severe slump in commodity prices.

Moody’s sticks with ‘negative’ outlook for Canadian banks in 2016

Moody’s Investors Service is sticking with its “negative” outlook for Canadian banks in 2016, pointing to challenges emanating from the struggling Canadian economy and a changing regulatory framework in the financial sector – even as the big banks continue to diversify abroad.

In its outlook, the credit rating agency pointed to Canada’s high household debt, the vulnerability of consumers with credit card balances and auto loans in a deteriorating economy, and the possibility that the federal government will create a so-called bail-in regime to protect taxpayers if banks fail.

Although this marks the third consecutive year that Moody’s has issued a negative outlook for the banks, this one stands out for its focus on asset risk, as the economy feels the impact of continuing low commodity prices. Moody’s expects the Canadian economy will expand by just 1.8 per cent in 2016, up from an estimate of 1 per cent growth this year.

“It’s not a huge thing. If it were only [asset risk], it would probably not be enough to tip the entire outlook into negative,” said David Beattie, senior vice-president of the financial institutions group at Moody’s. “But combined with the probable reduction in government support, that certainly does leave it firmly in negative.”

Even with the negative outlook, Moody’s has awarded the big banks some of its top credit ratings. The baseline credit assumption for Toronto-Dominion Bank is just three notches from the highest-quality debt. Bank of Nova Scotia is a notch below TD, followed another notch down by Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, Bank of Montreal and Royal Bank of Canada.

In other words, the negative outlook is applied to a relatively high level for the sector over all – and at a time when many of the banks have been making efforts to diversify beyond the Canadian economy. (…)

What It Means When Millennials Displace Boomers as Biggest U.S. Demographic
Confused smile Did You Forget Your Planes? Airport Takes Out Ad to Locate Owner

Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd. placed an advertisement Monday in the nation’s best-selling English daily asking for the “untraceable” owner of three Boeing Co. 747-200F planes to come and collect them. The planes are parked at three separate bays at KLIA in Sepang, outside the Malaysian capital, the Star newspaper ad showed.

FUTURE PRESIDENTS?